[Nataku X]

On the other hand it does give kids from worse schools a chance. Kids can't choose the schools they go to. My boyfriend went to an extremely wealthy private school, was a mediocre students with C's and a mediocre class rank (think Phillips Academy), and got accepted where I couldn't get in with straight A's from my public high school.

Automatic acceptance of 10% is a bit much. The top 2% should be sufficient.

[Dog Gone]

I'd go for 2%, because it would open up more slots for better-qualified students who just happen to live in school districts where the student population is extremely competitive. It's a waste of taxpayer money to send a bunch of kids to the flagship universities who are going to flunk out in a year.

I don't have any problem with diversity on our campuses. That's fine. But it ought to be made up of people of whatever color who have what it takes to earn a degree.