[Skooz]

I have no problem with it. It is a classic form of discipline, using peer pressure to enforce the rules.

My teachers and coaches used it often. I turned out just fine.

The only problem with this whole situation is the whiney dad who insists the rules are not for his little angel.

[malakhi]

I have no problem with it. It is a classic form of discipline, using peer pressure to enforce the rules. My teachers and coaches used it often. I turned out just fine.

That's fine, if you do it for a week. It loses its effectiveness as a strategy if you make it a permanent policy.