What part of his reasoning do you object to? Just curious.
Here is a link to his decision: http://www.wreg.com/Global/story.asp?S=1863039&nav=3HvDN4ah
It seems like Chinese parents can easily lose their parental rights in this case, unless they are perfect and without sins. They also seem to need to have money, so they can buy alot of gifts, to be good parents.