Posted on 05/12/2004 10:11:58 AM PDT by quidnunc
-snip-
Hugh Hewitt asked the big question tonight: of the worlds billion-plus Muslims, how many support the butchers who hacked the head off the Pennsylvania contractor? One percent? Ten? Either number stands for a lot of people. I was walking Jasper Dog while listening to the show, and a few thoughts popped up.
There are five reactions one could have to such acts, committed by a coreligionist: Endorsement, Indifference, Denial, Rejection, Participation.
Denial: Im sure youve heard this before: Islam is a religion of peace. But those people committed horrible violence in the name of Islam. Then they are not true Muslims. No Muslim could do this. Rinse, repeat. Its the theological equivalent of putting your hands over your ears and humming loudly.
Rejection: This would be speaking out singly or in concert with fellow Muslims, denouncing the acts without making the entire peroration an elaborate plinth on which to place the word BUT.
Indifference: Im a Muslim in Indonesia. I work in a bank. Im not particularly devout. I like a beer on a hot day, and you know what? Theyre all hot days. Some guys slit someones throat in Iraq. I think thats wrong and I think thats stupid. And what do you expect me to do about it?
Endorsement: Im not sure what constitutes endorsement silent pleasure among others not of the faith, chortling delight when youre with friends. Or perhaps nothing more than thanking Allah when you hear certain things have been done in Allahs name, and never acting or speaking a way that supports the jihadists cause.
Participation. Its obvious what this means.
Heres the crux: of these five aspects, four assist the jihadists in one form or another, and the fifth Rejection all too often takes a passive form. Hugh had a Somali Muslim on his show from Minneapolis; they spoke for almost 40 minutes, and the guys heart was in the right place. He sounded like a decent fellow. He said the Imam of his mosque regularly preached against the nutball Islamists. One hundred million more like him, please. But where are the rallies and marches outside the Saudi embassies demanding an end to funding extremism?
-snip-
(Excerpt) Read more at lileks.com ...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.