I do not sympathize overmuch with your quibble here, and your "logical" arguments reek of 13th century scholastic proofs of the existence of God. There is nothing innate about hydrogen, that we know of, that either precludes, or affirms a non-interventionist natural explanation for human self-awareness.
So do you affirm or deny the proposition that consciousness resides in the hydrogen atoms?
Given the world-view that hydrogen, given enough time, turned into people, the naturalistic world view would require one logically to believe the proposition, would it not?
No reeking intended. TM
Cordially,