[OXENinFLA]

some idiot ( OXENinFLA )

Hey now.

So instead of keeping this all to one thread you'd rather split it?

[OXENinFLA]

PING..................

[Eva]

If you read the discussion, the reason is that many posters do not read the messages, only the recent threads because they do not have time to sort through the messages.

[neverdem]

Oxen, this thread is already in the great beyond and no one can find it unless they deliberately go looking for it. I don't believe you can find it in the Editorial Sidebar any longer. That's why I told Eva and cyncooper that I wouldn't mind if either of them reposted the article. I understand the inconvenience of split threads, and I enjoy reading all the comments of threads to articles that I post as much as anyone. But Miniter's review of Clarke's book should have maximum circulation. The more people know about it the better.

Eva, please don't cast disparaging comments in the future. It doesn't advance any argument.