Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Victor Davis Hanson: When Should We Stop Supporting Israel?
VDH ^ | March 28, 2004 | Victor Davis Hanson

Posted on 03/28/2004 10:46:43 PM PST by quidnunc

The recent assassination of Sheik Saruman raises among some Americans the question — at what point should we reconsider our rather blanket support for the Israelis and show a more even-handed attitude toward the Palestinians? The answer, it seems to me, should be assessed in cultural, economic, political, and social terms.

Well, we should no longer support Israel, when…

Mr. Sharon suspends all elections and plans a decade of unquestioned rule.

Mr. Sharon suspends all investigation about fiscal impropriety as his family members spend millions of Israeli aid money in Paris.

All Israeli television and newspapers are censored by the Likud party.

Israeli hit teams enter the West Bank with the precise intention of targeting and blowing up Arab women and children.

Preteen Israeli children are apprehended with bombs under their shirts on their way to the West Bank to murder Palestinian families.

Israeli crowds rush into the street to dip their hands into the blood of their dead and march en masse chanting mass murder to the Palestinians.

Rabbis give public sermons in which they characterize Palestinians as the children of pigs and monkeys.

-snip-

(Excerpt) Read more at victorhanson.com ...


TOPICS: Editorial; Extended News; Foreign Affairs; Israel; War on Terror
KEYWORDS: israel; palestinians; unnecessaryexcerpt; vdh; victordavishanson; zionist
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100101-118 next last
To: Mr. Silverback
Went to Amazon to order and read some reviews on Victor Hanson. Seems Mr. Hanson is top shelf. I wasn't aware, as you probably realize.

Still, I've always been a strong advocate of Israel; supporting any and all military, financial, or political assistance from the US.

81 posted on 03/30/2004 8:26:54 PM PST by Paulie
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 65 | View Replies]

To: quidnunc
Hanson tries to use "the lessons of history" all the time. There is nothing wrong with this....though I think he is dead wrong in using the lessons of history to argue that we should keep throwing money down the Israel rathole which has only *detracted* from the hard-headed considerations of American national security.

It is time to take Israel, Egypt, and the other Middle Eastern countries off welfare. Like all welfare policies, they have failed to improve the situation for either the recipients or the "donor" (hard-working American taxpayers).

82 posted on 03/31/2004 2:29:00 PM PST by Austin Willard Wright
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 77 | View Replies]

To: quidnunc
show a more even-handed attitude toward the Palestinians?

This American doesn't want to hear any talk about supporting these savages. Remember the policy toward terrorists? You're with us or you're with the terrorists. The author of this crummy piece is with the terrorists

83 posted on 03/31/2004 2:32:16 PM PST by paul51
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Austin Willard Wright
Austin Willard Wright wrote: It is time to take Israel, Egypt, and the other Middle Eastern countries off welfare. Like all welfare policies, they have failed to improve the situation for either the recipients or the "donor" (hard-working American taxpayers).

We support israsel in far more ways than just giving them money, and in any case hanson does not make an issue oif aid to Israel.

If you don't like the idea of aid to Israel don't tell me or Hanson, go to Dubya's house, knock on the door and tell him.

Or maybe it would just be better to send him an email.

84 posted on 03/31/2004 2:38:16 PM PST by quidnunc (Omnis Gaul delenda est)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 82 | View Replies]

To: Paulie
Went to Amazon to order and read some reviews on Victor Hanson. Seems Mr. Hanson is top shelf. I wasn't aware, as you probably realize.

Hey, no big deal, it was an honest mistake. And thouh my suggestion may have sounded flip, I really do recommend An Autumn of War very, very highly. I don't think I've ever read a better book of collected essays.

Still, I've always been a strong advocate of Israel; supporting any and all military, financial, or political assistance from the US.

See posts 57, 71, 72 and further down. We have some useful idiots in the thread who call themselves freepers. Don't mistake them for trolls (although there is a resemblance) they just don't feel like fighting evil. It costs too much, surely you understand...

85 posted on 03/31/2004 3:23:38 PM PST by Mr. Silverback (Pre-empt the third murder attempt: Pray for Terri Schiavo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 81 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Silverback
OOPS! I'm glad you enjoyed it, but I didn't mean to be funny about such a serious subject.
86 posted on 03/31/2004 3:46:20 PM PST by upcountryhorseman (An old fashioned conservative)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 66 | View Replies]

To: Austin Willard Wright
Israel is perfectly free to defend itself but after over 100 billion dollars of aid since 1947, it should no longer be given a free ride off the American taxpayers. Our support for Israel (not to mention Egypt or Saudi Arabia) has only drawn us into ancient Middle East blood feuds and thus detracted from American defense needs.

And hey, just because Osama bin Laden wants us to do it doesn't mean it's a bad idea, right?

Our forefathers cried "Millions for defense, but not a penny for tribute!" A columnist from Decatur Alabama recently wrote that Commodore Decatur's sails billowed with those words. But as Israel suffers under the spiritual heirs of the Barbary Pirates (who certainly mean us as much ill as they do Israel), you say doing the right thing costs too much.

George Washington said the American cause was "the cause of mankind." But you say, "Hey, you're on your own, baby." I'm sure you would have opposed Lend Lease as well. Wouldn't want to get involved in a European "blood feud" would we?

Oh, and did you miss this in the article? (line breaks removed)

Israeli public figures routinely threaten the United States with terror attacks. Bin Laden is a folk hero in Tel Aviv. Jewish assassins murder American diplomats and are given de facto sanctuary by Israeli society. Israeli citizens celebrate on news that 3,000 Americans have been murdered. Israeli citizens express support for Saddam Hussein’s supporters in Iraq in their efforts to kill Americans.

How in the world is it not an American defense aim to oppose people who threaten us with terror attacks, lionize bin Laden, have been killing Americans since the 70s, harbor the killers of Americans, celebrate 9/11 and seek common cause with those who kill our troops now?

Palestine is not just Israel's enemy, but ours. And even if they hate us only because of our support for Israel (a ludicrous assertion, but we'll pretend for a moment) why would we appease people who hate us because we figured Holocaust II was something to prevent? Do you enjoy being pushed around by half-literate barbarians?

Oh, never mind. Let's just ignore the terrorists. It worked so well in 2001.

87 posted on 04/01/2004 12:43:14 PM PST by Mr. Silverback (Pre-empt the third murder attempt: Pray for Terri Schiavo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 72 | View Replies]

To: Dr._Joseph_Warren
Its very unfortunate that this person took a completely legitimate question and ruined it by inserting ludicrously extreme straw-man scenarios.

How did you miss the point of the article? These are all things Palestine has done. He merely rephrased them as if they were Israeli acts to show how ludicrous it is for anyone to be neutral or pro-Palestinian in this fight.

88 posted on 04/01/2004 12:47:06 PM PST by Mr. Silverback (Pre-empt the third murder attempt: Pray for Terri Schiavo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 73 | View Replies]

To: Austin Willard Wright
If someone can show me that Victor "bear any burden and pay any price" Hanson opposed a single war ever fought by Americans, I'll issue a humble apology for defaming him.

Please, enlighten us with your list of the ones we shouldn't have. Your comments on Israel/Palestine indicate that you would have opposed Lend Lease and, hey, why not just ignore the German declaration of war on 10 December? Just because a nation threatens to come kill your women and children doesn't mean you should fight them, or even help somebody else they're fighting. Hitler hadn't attacked Pearl Harbor, so no worries, right?

89 posted on 04/01/2004 12:51:17 PM PST by Mr. Silverback (Pre-empt the third murder attempt: Pray for Terri Schiavo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 74 | View Replies]

To: iconoclast
Yes, and that interjection was conceived in and of the same kind of starry-eyed optimism that triggered the presumptive invasion of Iraq

Please, share your wisdom: Why exactly should we ignore nations that harbor, train and fund terrorists? Because it worked so well in Afghanistan?

Also, if we hadn't supported the newborn Israeli state, there would have been a Holocaust II on the shores of the Med. You think that was an inappropriate move, then?

mind-boggling anticipation that these people of a primitive culture would WELCOME our dragging them into the twenty-first century.

Well of course people would hate to be rescued from having their tongues cut out or their daughters raped to make political points. What an arrogant bunch we are to think that all humans prefer peace and freedom to being terrorized by some tinpot idiot. How silly to believe that it's not the secret police or the brainwashing school systems that are the problem, it's really the basic inferiority of the Arab, it's so plain! </sarcasm>

90 posted on 04/01/2004 1:00:54 PM PST by Mr. Silverback (Pre-empt the third murder attempt: Pray for Terri Schiavo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 75 | View Replies]

To: A CA Guy
When hell freezes over.

Amen, sir.

91 posted on 04/01/2004 1:02:13 PM PST by Mr. Silverback (Pre-empt the third murder attempt: Pray for Terri Schiavo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 79 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Silverback
Why exactly should we ignore nations that harbor, train and fund terrorists?

Because we don't have a clue, NOT A CLUE, as to how to retaliate effectively against terrorists. That's why we chose to fight a CONVENTIONAL war against a toothless old tiger.

Your other points are just as flaccid so I won't waste my time addressing them.

92 posted on 04/01/2004 4:02:12 PM PST by iconoclast
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 90 | View Replies]

To: Lily4Jesus
The day the U S A stops supporting Israel the U S A will be history. GOD said:"I will bless those that blesses Israel and I will curse those that curses Israel..." GOD said it that settles it. This also applies in a a personal level too. In Jesus Name, AMEN.

Amen to that.

MM

93 posted on 04/01/2004 4:25:26 PM PST by MississippiMan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: iconoclast
Because we don't have a clue, NOT A CLUE, as to how to retaliate effectively against terrorists. That's why we chose to fight a CONVENTIONAL war against a toothless old tiger.

Hmmm...I wonder why you left the end of my line off when you quoted it? You know, the part where I asked, "Because it worked so well in Afghanistan?" I think you left it off because you don't have a clue how to respond effectively to it. What exactly are we supposed to do, sit around waiting for the next September 11th with our fingers up our noses? Three thousand Americans get killed by 19 guys with boxcutters in an hour and a half and you figure our response should be what? Anything but busting up training camps and killing terrorists? And if it's such a bad move, why are all of Khaddaffi's WMD programs deader than Disco? When a terrorist regime voluntarily gives up the means for nuclear blackmail, was it because our total inability to respond to terrorism scared him so much?

Oh, and I'm sure that Saddam's neighbors would be glad to hear your insights on his toothlessness. I'm sure every American pilot who got shot at those 2,500 times by Mr. Toothless will be glad to hear that hostile acts against American airmen no longer count as an act of war. I'm sure Al Qaida would love to hear about it, since they were working with him. Will you also be telling Mullah Omar that his Afghanistan was a mighty military power? Will you be telling all those people raped and tortured by Saddam's regime that they shouldn't have worried, because he was toothless?

Your other points are just as flaccid so I won't waste my time addressing them.

Suuuuuuurrrrreee they are...just like my mention of Afghanistan. Very convenient.

94 posted on 04/01/2004 4:42:06 PM PST by Mr. Silverback (Pre-empt the third murder attempt: Pray for Terri Schiavo.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 92 | View Replies]

To: Austin Willard Wright
Hanson never met a war he didn't like.

LOL.
Yes. You're right.

That's what military historians do.
Now you probably think that was a profound statement, and newcomers to FR might "agree" with you. However, I have been here long enough to see the banality and pettiness of that silly remark.

95 posted on 04/01/2004 5:23:51 PM PST by Publius6961 (50.3% of Californians are as dumb as a sack of rocks (subject to a final count).)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 57 | View Replies]

To: Publius6961
So under your theory historians of the holocaust like the holocaust and historians of Stalin's crimes like Stalin's crime. Silly indeed!
96 posted on 04/01/2004 5:25:57 PM PST by Austin Willard Wright
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 95 | View Replies]

To: Austin Willard Wright
The first rule of digging holes...

When you find yourself very deeply in a hole, the best way out is...

Stop digging.

My best advice to you is in the limey vernacular.
Do everyone a favor and P**s off.

97 posted on 04/01/2004 5:27:04 PM PST by Publius6961 (50.3% of Californians are as dumb as a sack of rocks (subject to a final count).)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 74 | View Replies]

To: Austin Willard Wright
It was originally your statement, Einstein, not mine.
So much for trying to give an idiot a graceful way out.

Enjoy your abysmal ignorance and faux moral posturing.

98 posted on 04/01/2004 5:30:59 PM PST by Publius6961 (50.3% of Californians are as dumb as a sack of rocks (subject to a final count).)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 96 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Silverback
Hmmm...I wonder why you left the end of my line off when you quoted it? You know, the part where I asked, "Because it worked so well in Afghanistan?"

The answer to that is quite simple, I could not tell if you were being sarcastic or not.

99 posted on 04/02/2004 1:58:27 AM PST by iconoclast
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 94 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Silverback
I'm sure every American pilot who got shot at those 2,500 times by Mr. Toothless will be glad to hear that hostile acts against American airmen no longer count as an act of war.

How many were shot down?

100 posted on 04/02/2004 2:01:44 AM PST by iconoclast
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 94 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100101-118 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson