What about polytheistic Americans ? I'm not an atheist but I'm not sure whether there is one creator or many . Whilst i think that the pledge is a very minor issue this idea that somebody is either a (Jewish/Christian/Islamic etc)monotheist or an atheist is absurd. Whats wrong with simply saying "may America be blessed" leaving who ( or who doesn't) do the blessing up to the individual.It's a little better but I'd say that a patriotic affirmation should be as all-inclusive as possible, especially when referring to the nation as "indivisible". The pre-1954 version does exactly that.
-Eric