There was a crude comic who once said getting women isn't hard, breaking up with women is hard. You've got it made. Go out with all of them, and when you're ready just tell them you voted for GWB, you're conservative, and you like to chop down trees just for the fun of it.
You could also tell them you hate cats and never really liked theirs. For some women I know that fit this stereotype, that would work too. Though saying you voted for GWB might accomplish your goal a little quicker.