[green iguana]

he had observed a man hit a woman inside a red and silver GMC truck

I read that. I hope that we can both agree that eyewitness' tend to be one of the least reliable types of evidence. If I hadn't read that Hiibel's daughter says that she was doing the driving and the hitting, I probably would move towards your position. But since she does, my guess (and yes, that's all that it is) is that Mr. Riddley saw some hitting going on and made the (usually correct) assumption that it was the man doing the hitting.

[cinFLA]

If I hadn't read that Hiibel's daughter says that she was doing the driving and the hitting, I probably would move towards your position. Why do you give more credence to his web-site (which contains multiple self-serving errors) than to the legal documents he has filed! If HIS legal document says she was on the passenger side of the truck, why do you doubt HIS LEGAL WORD?