GI Denied Medical Care After Speaking Out

WASHINGTON - An Operation Iraqi Freedom veteran says Army officials at Fort Knox, Ky., refused him medical treatment after he talked publicly about poor care at the base, which helped spark hearings in Congress.

Fort Knox officials charged that soldier, Lt. Jullian Goodrum, with being absent without leave and cut off his pay after he then went to a private doctor who hospitalized him for serious mental stress from Iraq, Goodrum said.

"They are coming after me pretty bad," said Goodrum, 33, a veteran who has served the military for more than 14 years, including the first Gulf War and Operation Iraqi Freedom.

He showed United Press International a form from Fort Knox that states that Fort Knox officials "do not want him in medical hold." Some soldiers are kept on medical hold during treatment while the Army determines their status.

Goodrum has now been hospitalized in a locked mental ward at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington, D.C. after turning himself in there Feb. 9. Doctors there say he has post-traumatic stress disorder from Iraq and major depression, and they worry he could hurt himself. He is not allowed to go down the hall from the inpatient psychiatric clinic for a Coke without an escort.

Goodrum said stress from Iraq, and the way he has been treated by the military since he returned, has made him so depressed he is lucky to be alive. He also has injuries to both wrists, in part from loading 65-pound shells on the USS Missouri when he was in the Navy in the first Gulf War. The ship pounded Iraqi troops in Kuwait and took fire from Iraqi tanks. An Iraqi Silkworm missile missed her bow by 30 yards.

Goodrum appeared in an Oct. 29 UPI article about more than 400 soldiers on medical hold at Fort Knox who were waiting weeks and sometimes months for medical treatment.

That article, and an article on a similar situation at Fort Stewart, Ga., sparked a series of hearings in Congress -- including a Jan. 21 appearance by Col. Keith Armstrong, garrison commander at Fort Knox, before a panel of the House Armed Services Committee.

Fort Knox spokeswoman Connie Shaffery said privacy rules prohibit her from commenting on Goodrum's case, unless he signed a waiver saying otherwise. He declined. Shaffery said a soldier who does not show up for duty is absent without leave.

"If a soldier is not at his or her duty station and is not in an authorized leave or pass status, he is absent without leave," Shaffery said. "When a soldier is listed as AWOL, it stops all pay and benefits. When instructed to return and they do not comply, that is a violation."

After appearing in the UPI article on Oct. 29, Goodrum asked for medical care on or about Nov. 7. He said he told Fort Knox officials that he was having a breakdown.

"I said I was having problems. I told them I felt like I was having a breakdown right there," Goodrum said. Goodrum said Fort Knox told him to go away. A handwritten note in Goodrum's records from Nov. 7 says, "Colonel Stevens do (sic) not want this patient to be in medical hold."

Goodrum said he then drove down an interstate highway at 5 miles an hour through rushing traffic. He said he was completely dysfunctional because of a combination of PTSD and what he says was retribution from his chain of command for speaking up about poor medical care at the base. He said he could have wound up dead.

"A truck could have run right over me," Goodrum said about that day. "It was a complete nervous breakdown."

Goodrum, a member of the Army Reserve, was named the 176th Maintenance Battalion's "Soldier of the Year" in 2001. He has received a host of awards, including the combat action ribbon, and positive reviews from superior officers.

"Lt. Goodrum is a truly outstanding junior officer," reads one performance evaluation from 2002. "In addition to his technical competence, he demonstrates great leadership potential. ... Promote to captain and select for advance military schooling."

Goodrum said his problems began in Iraq, working under combat conditions in a transportation company. There, he said, safety violations -- including the use of "deadlined" or broken vehicles -- resulted in the death of a 22-year old soldier. Goodrum appealed to the Army's Inspector General and Congress when he returned home.

After Goodrum sought medical help at Fort Knox on Nov. 7 and was denied, Goodrum's civilian doctor hospitalized him for PTSD and alerted Fort Knox.

Dr. Vijay Jethanandani wrote Fort Knox Nov. 15 that Goodrum needed medical leave until Dec. 7. The doctor kept officials there up to date on Goodrum's condition in a series of five letters.

"Unfortunately, recent intimidation, threats of being arrested for staying on medical leave from his superiors has resulted in recurrent psychiatric symptoms," Jethanandani wrote Dec. 3. "Until 11/26/03, Mr. Jullian Goodrum was progressing fairly well."

"It does not help that Mr. Goodrum was in combat with a unit in Iraq, where a superior officer ignored safety protocol jeopardizing the safety of soldiers and resulting in the death of one man," Jethanandani wrote. "Instead of following up on his complaints, it appears that some of his superiors on stateside may be penalizing him for reporting his superior officer in Iraq."

In the wake of the Fort Stewart and Fort Knox stories, last fall Undersecretary of Defense David S.C. Chu ordered that if medical care is not available on base, "medical commanders shall promptly refer patients to other military, Veteran Affairs, or civilian sources of care."

Goodrum said he showed Chu's memo to Fort Knox officials, but it did not help. "I told them they were ignoring an order from the undersecretary of Defense," Goodrum said.

Goodrum's medical files shows that Walter Reed medical staff also have been unable to get Fort Knox medical officials to discuss his case. "Patient is currently assigned to the medical hold company in Fort Knox, Ky., and to a Capt. Savage. Capt. Savage has NOT returned any phone calls from this office," his record states.

Soldiers at Fort Knox contacted UPI about another situation they consider a sign of poor care.

On Feb. 11, a soldier on medical hold at Fort Knox who served in Iraq apparently attempted suicide in the barracks. He was attached to a Special Forces unit in Iraq.

Soldiers there said he deeply slashed both of his wrists, spraying blood in the barracks hallway and around his room before being rushed to the hospital.

"If it was not for about three guys, if they had not applied direct pressure and immediate pressure, he would have died," said a soldier at Fort Knox who knows him.

Soldiers said they worry that Army officials did not act aggressively to address his problems, including heavy drinking, that appear to have surfaced since Iraq.

Shaffery said she could not comment on that case, either. "We are sensitive to psychiatric or suicide issues with all of our population," she said.

Goodrum appeared in an Oct. 29 UPI article about more than 400 soldiers on medical hold at Fort Knox who were waiting weeks and sometimes months for medical treatment.

Too bad he's not an illegal alien living in California. He would immediately get medical treatment.

I was permanently injured. I stayed in for a few years after that (on the condition that the surgery not be done). They got rid of the records pertaining to the LOD (duty injury), along with the Superior Unit award and others when it was time to get out. It's high time we removed such politics from the military, and there's probably only one way that I know of to do it.

Publicize it to the young folks until they earn a better reputation.

BTW, laws like the USFSPA must go, too, along with civilian divorce laws that affect reserve component personnel the same way. Raising the military family divorce rate is no way retain soldiers.

And as for the reserve components...? Friends, don't let friends go in without benefits, proper recognition and harsher punishments against employers who refuse to hire guard/reserve soldiers. ...and education for previous Era RA, long haired, druggie clerks who insult them.

I don't know all the facts on this case...but I can speak of experience at Ft. Knox's medical facilities. When I was in basic training I contracted an eye infection and was sent to the hospital. The care I received was great. But a few years later I was there attending a 2 week reserve training period and things went different. Once again...eye infection. It was painful. My eyes were swollen and I could not look at light. As a reservist I could not go to the hospital, I was sent to a local army clinic. The warrant officer said I had to go to the hospital. Back to the hospital as my eyes were about to pop out. There even thought I was telling them I was in pain, the doctors who took an oath to heal the sick told me they could not treat me. I had to go back to the clinic. I practically begged the warrant officer to help me. I will never forget that poor excuse of a human being...he actually laughed at me and asked me if I was enjoying my weekend for college money time in the army. I never did get treatment...I ended up taking 6 aspirins and going to bed. My commanding officer refused to do anything to help and I was trapped away from home with no money or vehicle to go to a local hospital if I even knew where it was.

I take the medical horror stories by reservists and guardsmen seriously. I have lived it.

I am still a US Army supporter with the exception of the medical corps. I feel sorry for our kids. They deserve better.

"Everyone who wants nationalized health care should be forced to use the military health care system for at least a year..."

Amen. If you want to experience it at it's finest obtain it in the Coast Guard. The CG doesn't have it's own doctors. They get some on loan from the Public Health Service and put them in uniform.

I won't go into details but one of our so-called doctors caused me some health problems...turned out he was a podiatrists.

Amen. If you want to experience it at it's finest obtain it in the Coast Guard. The CG doesn't have it's own doctors. They get some on loan from the Public Health Service and put them in uniform.

I won't go into details but one of our so-called doctors caused me some health problems...turned out he was a podiatrists.

When I got mobilized for Operation Enduring Freedom, I had to get a tooth fixed. I kid you not, my dentist was a WWII vet. A very nice guy but his hands were shaking and I think he had cataracts. Anyways, I went home on a pass before we shipped out and had my civilian dentist fix what the army dentist fixed. Without the private sector, military health care would really suck...

I have to add a couple of qualifiers to my own comments.

One of the finest men, and best doctors, I ever knew was a doctor with the Coast Guard.

The quality of care I've received at Madigan Army Hospital (Tacoma) has been world class.

My oldest son suffered from Ulcerative Colitis from the time he was 16. At the time we were at a small unit in Toledo, OH (please, no jokes) and under civilian medical care. When we came to Seattle our son's doctor urged us to put our son in the care of Madigan.

I won't mention his name but the head of the child's pediatric wing there was a well known, highly successful doctor in the south. When he watched the Gulf War on TV he sold his business and joined the Army.

When it became necessary to operate on our son he put together a fine team of surgeons (one from Walter Reed, one from Fitzsimmons) and assistants.

The surgery took 9 hours, our son recovered in half the normal time and leads a normal life now.

I will always take my hat off to his doctor, that team and Madigan Army Hospital.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.