Skip to comments.New Evidence Suggests Blackmun Should Have Recused Himself from Roe v Wade
Posted on 03/04/2004 9:51:43 PM PST by nickcarraway
Daughter's teen pregnancy and failed shotgun marriage played a part in ruling
WASHINGTON, March 4, 2004 (LifeSiteNews.com) - The late Harry Blackmun was the Supreme Court Justice who supported and authored the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision which sanctioned the legalization of murder by striking down the US abortion law. In an interview Sunday, Blackmun's daughter Sally Blackmun, the executor of his private papers, revealed the background behind his ruling. The interview is a result of her decision to release his private documents for public purview this week.
According to his daughter, Justice Blackmun's choice to strike down the abortion law had much to do with input he sought from her. "Roe was a case that Dad struggled with," Blackmun told the feminist news service, WomensEnews. "It was a case that he asked his daughters' and wife's opinion about."
In 1966, while a 19-year-old sophomore at Skidmore College in Saratoga Springs, N.Y., Blackmun discovered she was pregnant. "It was one of those things I was not at all proud of, that I was not at all pleased with myself about. It was a big disappointment to my parents," she said. "I did what so many young women of my era did. I quit college and married my 20-year-old college boyfriend. It was a decision that I might have made differently had Roe v. Wade been around."
Sally told WomensEnews that her marriage lasted only six years, and her college education took almost as long. "Even that might not have occurred, if she had carried to term," she said. In 1972, Justice Blackmun sought his daughter's opinion on the Roe v. Wade decision.
At the time of the decision, Sally Blackmun lived and worked in Washington. Her father gave her advance notice that he was to disclose his ruling, in order for her to be present when it was revealed. "I was very pleased with the decision and the fact that it gave women that right of choice," she told WomensEnews. "Dad always felt that it was the right thing to do and the necessary thing to do toward the full emancipation of women in this country. So we certainly were in favour of what he did."
Sally is an attorney for Darden Restaurants Inc., which operates a chain of restaurants nationwide. She is to be named chair of Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando in May, an organization for whom she has raised $3 million to construct a new abortion facility. Rita Lowndes, Former Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando chair says of Blackmun's work, "Sally sees it as a way to honor her father's legacy."
By Cynthia L. Cooper
As Justice Blackmun's archives are about to go public, the daughter of the author of the Supreme Court decision Roe v. Wade talks about the collection, the hate mail her father brought home and her own emergence as a pro-choice advocate.
(WOMENSENEWS)--Justice Harry A. Blackmun, the U.S. Supreme Court justice famous for his pro-choice decision in the 1973 case of Roe v. Wade, had a habit of bringing home his hate mail.
When most of the archives of the Nixon appointee become public this week, a large collection of those letters will be available for the entire world to read. But for now they're still in the control of his daughter Sally Blackmun, the middle of three sisters and trustee of the collection of her father, who died in 1999.
She gave a Women's eNews a look at some samples:
". . . I hope you croak you old bastard. You are a worthless, pathetic excuse for a Supreme Court justice. You can't die soon enough. You are responsible for the deaths of thousands of unborn children, which you cloak in 'woman's rights,'" said one letter-writer.
"I guess we were appalled that people were as nasty as they were," said Sally Blackmun, who is senior associate general counsel for Orlando-based Darden Restaurants, Inc. Her father, she said, responded by saving every scrap of paper. On March 4, massive files, including 100 folders of letters, will be opened to the public at the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C. according to his daughter, a corporate lawyer in Orlando, Fla.
Emerging From Reticence
For many years, Sally Blackmun was reticent to speak out about the abortion issue. "I felt, being in the law, that I needed to distance myself from Dad, do my own thing," she told Women's eNews. But in the process of preserving the archives and legacy of her father, with whom she had a great affinity, she began to emerge as a calm and assured voice for women's right to choose.
"They both evolved," said Harold Koh, "She had a unique understanding of the court. She came to realize that she stood for the same things as her father." Koh, the dean-appointee of Yale Law School, is a former Blackmun law clerk who consulted on collection.
Sally agrees. "If we were to go back to the dark days before Roe, many people who take it for granted would be totally shocked by the reversal and what it means. It weighs heavy on me," she said. Honoring her father, she discovered, meant refusing to stand silently aside and, like her father's opinions, she is steadily becoming part of the ongoing legacy of Roe v. Wade.
Her first forays into talking openly about Roe v. Wade came late in her father's life, when he requested that she represent him at award ceremonies. Before a Planned Parenthood group in upstate New York, she found herself overwhelmed with memories of her own experiences at Skidmore College in Saratoga Springs in pre-Roe days and described them.
There, as a 19-year-old sophomore, Sally learned she was pregnant in 1966. "It was one of those things I was not at all proud of, that I was not at all pleased with myself about. It was a big disappointment to my parents," she said in an interview. "I did what so many young women of my era did. I quit college and married my 20-year-old college boyfriend. It was a decision that I might have made differently, had Roe v. Wade been around," she said. It was, she said, one of the most difficult periods of her life.
Three weeks after a quiet wedding, she had a miscarriage. But her life had already changed. Her student career at Skidmore was cut short and she moved to join her new spouse in another state. The marriage lasted six years and it took her nearly as long to complete her college requirements. Even that might not have occurred, if she had carried to term, she said.
Sally, who married again and has two daughters, now speaks regularly to groups about Roe. She volunteers as a court-appointed guardian to represent the needs of infants who are abandoned, most commonly by young women who feel that they have no options.
Four years ago, she joined the board of the Planned Parenthood of Greater Orlando, leading a $3 million campaign to build a new facility in Central Florida. In May, she will assume the role of chair. Rita Lowndes, a former chair, said, "Our local chapter is filling a huge need. Sally sees it as a way to honor her father's legacy."
Most recently, Sally wrote the introduction to "The War on Choice: The Right-Wing Attack on Women's Rights and How to Fight Back," written by Gloria Feldt. In it, she repeated an alert sounded by her father about a court environment increasingly hostile to reproductive rights. "A chill wind blows," he wrote in 1989.
Lightening Rod for Backlash
After he authored Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision on abortion that changed women's lives, Justice Blackmun became a lightening rod for backlash. The case established abortion as a decision protected by a constitutional right to personal privacy. It also prevented states from subjecting women and their doctors to criminal sanctions for giving or getting abortions in the first trimester. While restrictions on abortion could be imposed thereafter, states could never jeopardize a woman's life or health.
People infuriated by the decision picketed Blackmun wherever he traveled. In 1989, a bullet came zinging through his living room window.
"After that, he didn't go out anywhere in public without some kind of police protection," Sally Blackmun said.
When the opinion in Roe was assigned to Blackmun, he canvassed his family, Sally Blackmun said. "Roe was a case that Dad struggled with. It was a case that he asked his daughters' and wife's opinion about."
Because she was living in D.C. and working at the Nixon White House as an executive assistant for the Council on International Economic Policy, her father let her know when the decision was to be announced so she could sit in.
"I remember that it was very tense in the courtroom, very crowded. The decorum is such that people aren't yelling and screaming and carrying on. We didn't know how he was going to come down on it. And I was very pleased with the decision and the fact that it gave women that right of choice," said Blackmun. "Dad always felt that it was the right thing to do and the necessary thing to do toward the full emancipation of women in this country. So we certainly were in favor of what he did."
Katherine Kolbert, a lawyer in Philadelphia, recalled that Justice Blackmun grew even stronger in other abortion cases after Roe by insisting that women's ability to control their reproductive lives is central to their full equality. Kolbert appeared before the Supreme Court in a 1992 abortion case that permitted new restrictions on abortion, while still upholding a women's right to choose. Kolbert represented the pro-choice perspective of the abortion rights groups, arguing that Roe should be upheld. Blackmun voted to uphold Roe and objected to new restrictions.
The archives created by Blackmun's memos, drafts and personal notes will offer the most comprehensive behind-the-scenes view of Supreme Court decision-making yet, said Yale law school's Koh. The collection consists of 522,000 items, including 38 hours of oral commentary. The index alone is 360 pages. Hundreds of scholars are clamoring to dive in.
They won't be disappointed, said Koh. "Many, many surprises."
Cynthia L. Cooper, a journalist in New York with a background as a lawyer, writes frequently about topics of reproductive rights, justice and equality.
I guess we should look at those infants as "unjustly born".
Well son, if Grandpa had only moved a little quicker on Roe I could have gotten rid of you a long time ago.
So you can't get an education after you give a baby up for adoption? It HAS to be KILLED? What a selfish b*tch.
Was that "it" having sex before marrying that guy, getting pregnant, or both? She had the right to choose to say no to the guy she eventually divorced, just as she had the right to divorce him or never marry him in the first place. She had all those choices, and yet claims to be appalled at people having strong feelings about taking human life ostensibly to make it easier for her and others like her to choose to say no to marriage.
She wasn't proud of herself for getting pregnant. And millions of innocent babies have been murdered as result. Why don't I feel sorry for her initial marital discord?
Yes, her life changed when she got married to the guy she would later divorce. That is what caused her to take 6 years to get a degree, not being pregnant only to later miscarry.
Yeah! What a smack in the face to her kid. Are only planned kids to be loved?
So she regrets not having an abortion? How sick.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.