Before going any further, I would like to clarify myself regarding my "rules of engagement", because I see myself drifting too far into the camp of apparent negativity, and that's not where I like to be.
In the interest of brevity, I'll use a bullet-point format and try to be succinct:
1) I'm enjoying the discussion, and want to make it clear that my tendency toward fiery prose is more from habit than anything else. Try as I might to keep myself in check, when I later review some of my more strident posts, I usually cringe at how hard-edged they sound. I enjoy direct and passionate debate, but I despise ad hominem attacks (even though I regrettably indulge in them now and then). So up front, I request that you bear in mind that, to me at least, the tone I wish to adopt is more one of forthrightness than anger (which I do not feel toward you) or self-righteous indignation. We're exchanging viewpoints, and mine is no more valuable than yours or anyone else's.
2) I have no intention of going all "anti-Semitic" on you. I am reluctant to hurl such a label even at genuine, avowed, self-described anti-Semites, because I reject the culture of victimization that has developed around the term. I also try to avoid using labels to shut down discussions, because I consider it intellectually dishonest. So even if you were sitting there dressed in an SS uniform (which I know you're not, of course), I would prefer to talk rather than shout epithets at you.
3) When I accuse you of bizarre sophistry, I am assailing your opinions or behavior (or my perception of it), not you as a person. Even if I think what you are saying is stupid, that doesn't mean I think you are. I consider myself a reasonably intelligent person, but I do many stupid things (I consider myself something of an expert on it, in fact). I actually have a great deal of respect for all my fellow FReepers, even those I routinely disagree with on fundamental issues (because of their stupid positions :^). So please bear that in mind.
I am hopeful that spelling this out will help mitigate what might otherwise seem like vitriolic cat-fighting. There is no malice here.
The truth is that I love to debate ideas, it is a passion of mine, I'm not as full of myself as I may seem, and that even my "nastiest" posts are invariably accompanied by a smile, chuckle or full-on laughter as I hit the "Post" button. I love this place.
Now, back to tearing into you... ;^)