Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: stuartcr
But fornication and desecration are objective moral evils. My beliefs have nothing to do with that.

If you want to argue that, say, fornication and desecration are in fact objective goods, or at least not evils, then do so. If you want to dive into ethical subjectivism and stop the discussion with a sophomoric "well, that's just what you believe" then you prove yourself unwilling to enter into argument.

Here, I'll make an argument for you to enter and to refute, if you can:

Fornication is an objective moral evil, for the following reasons:

First, it infringes upon the rights of marriage. Only spouses have the right to sex. They have this right because they have already vowed themselves to each other in a gift of self. The act of physical love is the consumation and highest expression of this full gift of self. Spouses' very body language in the conjugal act speaks marriage.

Second, fornication, no matter how well contracepted, leads to illegitimate children. These children are either killed off in the womb--another evil--or raised in domestic situations where the father is not committed to the mother--vastly inferior to married households.

Third, fornication, even contracepted fornication, is a habit of passion unguided by reason. Fornicators ignore and avoid the rational good of marriage. Though their bodies speak the language of total self-gift, they do not give themselves totally to each other by an act of willed committment. Thus they are inconsistent and irrational.

Knock my arguments down, and I'll admit my opinions are nothing more than irrational belief.

47 posted on 02/19/2004 10:54:04 PM PST by Dumb_Ox
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 46 | View Replies ]


To: Dumb_Ox
I have no desire to argue anything..you stated that what I said was obvious, and you asked for a conclusion.

Personally, I believe, as are most if not all moral viewpoints, that they are morally relative...not objective moral evils.

There's no arguement to be had...what is considered good/evil now, most likely was not at some time in the past and maybe in the future...that's just the way it is.

Please offer proof that only spouses have the right to sex.

Fornication that does not result in a pregnancy obviously does not lead to illegitimate children.

Please offer proof that fornication is an unguided passion, and that a willed commitment is necessary for a man and woman to be satisfied.

There's only one caveat...you can't use the bible as proof.

Your beliefs are not irrational, just the behavior you exhibit in trying to pass them off as truths, and the apparent inability to accept others beliefs that are not in agreement with yours.
49 posted on 02/20/2004 5:45:20 AM PST by stuartcr
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 47 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson