Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: optimistically_conservative
Army General Order 4361, dated June 9, 1968, states that the Silver Star was awarded to U.S. Army Capt. Max ."

It was with curiosity that I read the language contained in the award commemorating Max's gallantry. Curious because I have read it more than a dozen times on other soldier's Silver and Bronze Star histories. When I served in the Army from 1975 to '81, I encountered many a staff officer with the award plaque on their walls, all virtually with the identical language. After a while of seeing this amazing similarity, I had to ask our Battalion Adjutant how this could be? (ignorant little 2nd Louy that I was.)

What came from his files was, to explain the matter, was a "cookbook" that described the proper format and language necessary to procure the appropriately requested award for a given individual. The format was replete with examples of each award language that was guaranteed to procure the requested award; and of course, these examples all mirrored the histories I had noticed before. These cookbook depictions even left blanks for the insertion of dates, units, and places of the supposed action of gallantry.

Furthermore, its not surprising that a horrifically wounded soldier would have an award recommendation made about an event that "occurred" just days before his incident of grievous injury or death. War is hell, and you have only to witness the shattered lives of so many that have returned from the fires of its belly to know that these people have sacrificed more than the common man. They've been there, done that, and are forever marked as special.

But.. don't pull out the bag of medals as proof of honor or valor. The dishonesty that permeates the process of granting such kudos is too suspect to be evidence of anything. The true laurel wreath is in knowing the guy/gal was able to serve and did so honorably.

72 posted on 02/12/2004 5:52:57 AM PST by Thommas ("Beam me up Scottie, there are no intelligent anarchists here...")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies ]


To: Thommas
Awards, without knowing the person and the events leading to the award, speak little on thier own (although I remain in strict admiration of CMOH recipients). This is sad, but has been historically true, and the context of the award remains more important than the award itself. I am also aware that too many deserving were not awarded for extraneous considerations of rank, race, favoritism and quotas, among others.

You want to question whether Cleland deserved the Silver Star? Be my guest. Just be aware at the level of Silver Star, the citation on the certificate is cookbook, but the write up for justification and orders that accompany the award certificate are more descriptive. There are still some catch phrases and templating, but not the same as the limitation for the actual certificate.
99 posted on 02/12/2004 6:40:52 AM PST by optimistically_conservative (This tagline recently seen at Taglinus FreeRepublicus)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 72 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson