Replies

You are simply belied by your own words again. You deny your own comment, quoted below, written at # 279..
Thus.. -- You claim "the people " in the Second Amendment, whose right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, --- are only comprised of:

#279 -- "the members of the militia which was stated as a justification for the 2d". -- #279

Obviously the people referenced in the 2nd are the 'People of the United States'.
-- It will be interesting to see you dig yourself out of your own "trick question" hole.
Two bits you won't even try to explain yourself on that howler..
-308-

False as usual. I stated that the justification given in the 2d was because "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

Nope, -- you said that 'the people' referenced only applied to militia.

If you have a problem complain to the Founders those are their words. They were justifying it with militia needs not I. I have repeatedly posted WHO the militia was "every able bodied (free) man."

And, you thereby attempted to justify the AWB renewal as only the milita supposedly have a right to assault weapons..

Don't you get tired of these distortions. Can you not find things to argue with me about which I have actually SAID.
Others don't have your problem.

How weird.. Many "others" here have been complaining of your distortions of our BOR's for this whole thread..

NOne of those atttributions to me are true. I have repeatedly stated WHAT the militia is WHO composes it and WHY the 2d was written according to the Founders.

No one has complained that I have distorted their words or tried to twist their meaning. They may say that I don't interprete certain things correctly but not that I have willfully misinterpreted their words particularly when they have corrected any misinterpretation I may have had.

YOU on the other hand just ignore what I say and yammer on with what I DIDN'T say. But being rather clueless you make the mistake of printing the words I did say thus proving to any reader that you are lying.

The posts clearly show that I never placed the militia in opposition to the people nor claimed that non-militia were not entitled to possess arms. Not that this will stop you from lying again.