[tiamat]

We aren't going to agree.

I HAVE studied Church history, of several flavors. I can back what I am saying up.

Now *I* am being friendly about this. Why aren't you?

Tia

[A.A. Cunningham]

Making a subjective remark, which has been repeatedly refuted and which I can most charitably describe as nothing more than a lie, can hardly be characterized as friendly. If you are as learned as you claim to be then please translate the phrase I posted and tell us where it originated. Also, please provide a detailed review of Cochini's "Apostolic Origins of Priestly Celibacy" which also refutes your allegation and which you no doubt have voraciously read.