[Noumenon]

This article is based on wishful thinking that Islam has within it the yearning for freedom and cultural advancement common to mankind through the ages--it doesn't. It has within it the mandate to possess, destroy and replace everything non-Muslim with itself. It is an unworkable system because, like Communism, it is based on a lie and denial/repression of what is noble in human nature.

Precisely. I like V.S. Naipaul, take on Islam:

Islam destroyed India. There is this ill-informed idea that it was the British, in the short time that they were there, that ruined and defaced all those temples you see. The bitter fact is that the people of India were ill-equipped to face the organized military power of Islam and were destroyed by it. The intellectual life of India, the Sanskrit culture, stops at 1000AD. Islam was the greatest calamity that befell it. Now people think only the Muslims built anything but what they brought was a slave culture that lasted in some parts of India until almost the other day. To be a Muslim you have to destroy your history, to stamp on your ancestral culture. The sands of Arabia is all that matters. This abolition of the self is worse than the colonial abolition, much worse.
-- VS Naipaul (Nobel Prize, Literature, 2001)

[AM2000]

Which Naipaul book is that excerpt from?