[NittanyLion]

badmouthing McNabb? Try badmouthing the media.

On that we agree. However, there is a group of folks on this site that desire to run down McNabb for something he had no part in. They should, as you suggest, badmouth the media, who has perpetuated this "controversy".

McNabb is a fine average QB.

Technically average. From a leadership standpoint, far above average. The Eagles aren't the winningest team of the last 4 years by accident...

[Moby Grape]

Nittany... I agree that McNabb is a leader...he is usually cool and can make big plays...ALL teams want players who can pull off big plays when they have to be had, but it is my view that the DEFENSE made them a winning team the last four years...big play makers by themselves cannot assure success...the odds catch up with them. It takes balance to go the the big game.

[blackie]

"The Eagles aren't the winningest team of the last 4 years by accident..."

Maybe it's strength of schedule ~ how else can you explain their total collapse and big time choke when they get to the big games?