To: DMCA
That section of copyright law applies to most, if not all, copyrighted materials, including music, audio, video and small sections of source codeIt applies not at all to source code. I'm in the software business, and there is no "fair use" of any of our software unless we grant permission.
Also, exactly how does one "fair use" music? And how does one control the individual who copies music and distributes it to his friends for free?
Theft, in other words.
24 posted on
01/18/2004 9:07:10 PM PST by
sinkspur
(Adopt a shelter dog or cat! You'll save one life, and maybe two!)
To: sinkspur
I will answer your points in reverse order.
How do 'fair use' music? Easy, use it in a classroom for teaching or a short segment on a news program. Things like that.
It applies to most, if not all, copyrighted materials. If you keep the source code secure than that makes it impossible, but if the source code is released it is allowable to use it if you follow the fair use guidelines.
Fair use of computer programs is prohibited not by law, but by they fact that most computer programs function as one unit that you can not take small portions out of and still have them function.
Seeing as how I derive income from the production of copyrighted works I would appreciate it if you would stop calling me a thief.
26 posted on
01/18/2004 9:24:54 PM PST by
DMCA
(TITLE 17 Chapter 1 Sec 107)
To: sinkspur
What source code do you own personally?
To: sinkspur
Also, exactly how does one "fair use" music? OK, just this once I'll do your homework for you:
1. "Space-Shifting" (e.g. copying a CD to tape in order to play it in a car that has a tape player but no CD player).
2. "Time-Shifting" (e.g. copying a radio broadcast for later listening).
3. "Format-Shifting) (e.g. converting CD audio to MP3 files for use in an MP3 player).
71 posted on
01/20/2004 10:40:59 AM PST by
steve-b
To: sinkspur
"Also, exactly how does one "fair use" music?"
Back in the LP days one could record a copy onto tape for one's use. Nowadays one might be expected to buy one copy for the home, and buy another copy to play in the car. If I recorded a copy for a friend was that theft? If I loan a friend a book to read have I sinned? Do libraries pay authors royalties? Has anyone you know ever disseminated the accounts or descriptions of a major league ball game without the express written permission of major league baseball? That fiend! The big issue here is over those that sell multiple copies, not individuals making one or two copies.
76 posted on
01/20/2004 11:04:54 AM PST by
bk1000
(put him back in the spider hole)
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson