[Jorge]

He DID NOT tell another poster he would prefer a woman die from AIDS than commit the evil of having sex with a condom.

Then explain to us what this exchange means;

_____________________________

"think about it. Married people get aids from either preexisting sexual activity or from blood. Now in the context of marital sex with a spouse with aids, would you be opposed to condom usuage." 9 posted on 01/13/2004 10:42:06 AM EST by cajungirl

To: cajungirl "Yes. The act of contraception is intrinsically evil One may never commit an intrinsically evil act even if some limited good may come from it." 10 posted on 01/13/2004 11:10:17 AM EST by johnb2004 __________________________

The fact is you can't. He clearly says that it would be better for the woman to catch AIDS than to commit the evil of contraception.

[Polycarp IV]

Then explain to us what this exchange means; He clearly says that it would be better for the woman to catch AIDS than to commit the evil of contraception.

No, he is saying that sex with a condom is not an option, since one may never commit an intrinsically evil act even if some limited good may come from it, therefore the only option is abstaining.

Until johnb2004 personally validates my interpretation or yours, you would be prudent to stop twisting his words and putting words in his mouth.