[swarthyguy]

I think this is basically a sensible proposal, at least for the businesses dependent on these laborers, and to help boost the SS security system by getting these people paying taxes and FICA.

However, I wish Bush would stop this semantic hair splitting and call it what it is - An AMNESTY. Not being honest about the terminology is positively Clintonian.

None of these people will leave after the 3 year limit and by then, the laws will allow their bluecards to be converted to green cards.

[kevao]

I think this is basically a sensible proposal, at least for the businesses dependent on these laborers, and to help boost the SS security system by getting these people paying taxes and FICA.

The current illegals will not be participating in the Social Security system. Once registered, they must be paid at least minimum wage (plus benefits) in the formal economy. Under these conditions, most will be unable to find work -- they will be undercut by a new wave of illegals willing to work for less than minimum.