15 years from now they'll be another 10-15 million illegals on top of the 10-15 million that are getting amnesty
Nope, that's where you are wrong. There is NO amnisty here. A guest worker can stay for 3 years. If they want to become citizens they can apply just like anyone else but they have to go to the back of the line. In order to stay here they must be fully employed and they must pay a fee to remain in the country (if they are employed that will be no problem). If you become unemployed you have to go home. You can apply for another job, but you must do it from your home country.
Jobs must be advertised and if an American applies, you can not offer the job to ANY guest worker.
I know what the proposal is, you don't have to repeat it to me
What I am saying is that anyone who believes that these policies will be enforced is very naive.
Illegals and employers of illegals broke the law before, but they'll obey it now?
The government won't enforce the laws now, but it will start now?
do you actually believe that? I don't.
¿Qué? Do you even know what an amnesty is? "An act of pardon by a legislative authority which effaces a punishment."
Illegals are here because they broke our immigration laws. That's where the term "illegal" comes from, in case you're wondering. People who break laws are criminals. Criminals are normally subject to punishment. But not in this case because George Bush is granting to these criminals not the deportation they deserve, but rather legal status.
How can you say this is not an amnesty? Is any illegal going to be punished in any way for having violated U.S. immigration laws?