[mabelkitty]

She picked the numbers at random. Then she said she's been playing the same numbers for two years.

That alone is contradictory.

Plus, Battles knew the date and time of sale. That's a whopper.

[Bikers4Bush]

She picked them at random TWO YEARS ago and has been playing them since.

The fact that she knew the date and time is no whopper. There are a number of ways she could have found that out in three days. Hell the store owner knew that info so no doubt others did and passed along that info.