Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

UK: Spirit 'Far More Complex' Than Beagle 2
http://www.news.scotsman.com/latest.cfm?id=2370867 ^

Posted on 01/04/2004 10:08:45 AM PST by Orbital Velocity

The Spirit rover probe’s success in landing on Mars so soon after Beagle 2’s ominous silence may not be entirely surprising when the missions are compared.

The disparity in the price tags alone is enough to raise a few eyebrows.

The Americans have splashed out 820 million (£460 million) on their Mars Exploration Rover (MER) mission, which includes a sister rover to Spirit, Opportunity.

But the cash-strapped Brits, who unlike Nasa cannot throw huge amounts of taxpayers’ money at space projects, spent a paltry £140 million on the Mars Express package overall.

While Spirit itself cost around 400 million (£220 million), Beagle 2 is estimated to have been a snip at about £45 million.

And it is not hard to see how the extra cash might have been spent.

Engineering-wise, Spirit is a far more complex animal than Beagle 2, which was designed to carry out experiments at one spot.

In contrast the six-wheeled American vehicle, which is about the size of a golf cart, is free to roam, observing its surroundings through a pair of cameras perched on the end of a long “neck”.

As well as stereoscopic vision, the rover has an extendable arm fitted with tools for grinding out and examining rock samples.

The rovers have “brains” that allow them to make some of their own decisions when, for instance, assessing hazards in their path. They are also able to carry out their own “health checks”.

Within a shell-like body no bigger than a motorcycle wheel, Beagle 2 carries an incredible array of instruments, including an on-board laboratory for analysing samples, a rock drill and a burrowing mole.

But while Nasa’s spacecraft are crammed with back-up systems, Beagle 2, the brainchild of Professor Colin Pillinger, has no built-in redundancy.

Unlike Beagle 2, Spirit is not designed to look for direct signs of life. Instead, it will search for the most likely places where life may have existed in the past.

The projects also differ in background and underlying general spirit.

The MER mission is part of a grand long-term Nasa strategy which will later involve collecting samples and bringing them back to Earth.

Spirit and Opportunity, due to arrive on Mars on January 24, are both highly risky missions and hugely important to Nasa’s reputation and future.

In contrast the Beagle 2 project was put together on a shoestring by clever and inventive engineers faced with the seemingly impossible task of building a lander capable of searching for life on Mars that weighed less than 200lb.

They had to do this at a fraction of the cost of Nasa space missions, and in record time.

The Government and European Space Agency (ESA) are underwriting at least some of the cost, but fundraisers had to go cap in hand to potential sponsors and the business of negotiating deals has been continuing.

More unusual ways to pay for the project also had to be found.

Part of the campaign involved “Brit-pop” musicians Blur, two of whom are keen amateur astronomers. Bass guitarist Alex James and drummer David Rowntree attended exhibitions to help attract sponsors, and composed Beagle 2’s nine-note call-sign tune.

Maverick artist Damien Hirst produced a “spot painting” to be carried to Mars and used by scientists to calibrate Beagle 2’s instruments.


TOPICS: Miscellaneous; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: beagle2; jpl; mars; nasa; spiritrover
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-38 last
To: Orbital Velocity
But the cash-strapped Brits, who unlike Nasa cannot throw huge amounts of taxpayers’ money at space projects, spent a paltry £140 million on the Mars Express package overall. </>

They forgot about the little rover a few years back. This tells me that the British ecconomy is not big enough. It also tells me that this british author would be happiest if 0 dollars were spent on thses programs.

21 posted on 01/04/2004 10:39:32 AM PST by longtermmemmory (Vote!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: FreedomCalls
Well, since you probably don't live in England, than why the hell should you care how much it cost?
22 posted on 01/04/2004 10:39:58 AM PST by Central Scrutiniser (Never, ever, ever trust a Tax Protester that wants your money...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | View Replies]

To: medscribe
Could be the Brits saying they need as much money as the Americans to avoid future embarassment.
23 posted on 01/04/2004 10:42:12 AM PST by longtermmemmory (Vote!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Orbital Velocity
Someone should tell our British friends that an alibi works best when you establish it in advance.
24 posted on 01/04/2004 10:42:23 AM PST by PUGACHEV
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Orbital Velocity
Maybe our Rover can drive
over to their Beagle and give it a bone.


25 posted on 01/04/2004 10:44:56 AM PST by Major_Risktaker
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: medscribe
The Brits accomplished a big feat by simpley hitting Mars. I say hitting vs land on, becasue it looks like Beagle 2 most liekly went splat. Never the less, distance and potential for failure even before reaching mars orbit are astronomical, let allow landing.
26 posted on 01/04/2004 10:47:33 AM PST by Turbo Pig (If They Don't Respect US, They Should At Least Fear US.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Central Scrutiniser
Well, since you probably don't live in England, than why the hell should you care how much it cost?

Since The Scotsman newspaper is not published in America, tell me why the hell should The Scotsman care what the American mission costs, much less splash a story about its costs (to Americans) all across its front page?

27 posted on 01/04/2004 10:48:05 AM PST by FreedomCalls (It's the "Statue of Liberty," not the "Statue of Security.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies]

To: FreedomCalls
They shouldn't, what ya gonna do?
28 posted on 01/04/2004 10:49:19 AM PST by Central Scrutiniser (Never, ever, ever trust a Tax Protester that wants your money...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 27 | View Replies]

To: Central Scrutiniser
They shouldn't, what ya gonna do?

Well, I would:

"... remind them that their £45 million for Beagle is money down the drain with absolutely nothing to show for it, whereas our $400 million for Spirit will actually accomplish something."

And we come back full circle.

29 posted on 01/04/2004 10:59:54 AM PST by FreedomCalls (It's the "Statue of Liberty," not the "Statue of Security.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 28 | View Replies]

To: Central Scrutiniser
This was an excellent attempt by the Brits. Nobody stands up and walks the first time, they will learn from this one and the next will be better. That's the way it works.
30 posted on 01/04/2004 11:00:30 AM PST by McGavin999
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies]

To: Turbo Pig
Did Spirit land anywhere near Beagle2?

It would be cool if it could find Beagle2
31 posted on 01/04/2004 11:03:58 AM PST by mylife
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 26 | View Replies]

To: Orbital Velocity
Their orbiter has several different instruments onboard. The following is stolen from the ESA website:

Mars Express orbiter instruments

HRSC

High Resolution Stereo Camera (HRSC)

The HRSC will image the entire planet in full colour, 3D and with a resolution of about 10 metres. Selected areas will be imaged at 2-metre resolution. One of the camera's greatest strengths will be the unprecedented pointing accuracy achieved by combining images at the two different resolutions. Another will be the 3D imaging which will reveal the topography of Mars in full colour.

"As the 2-metre resolution image is nested in a 10-metre resolution swath, we will know precisely where we are looking. The 2-metre resolution channel will allow us to just pick out the Beagle 2 lander on the surface," says Gerhard Neukum, HRSC Principal Investigator from Freie Universität Berlin, Germany.

OMEGA Visible and Infrared Mineralogical Mapping Spectrometer

OMEGA will build up a map of surface composition in 100 m squares. It will determine mineral composition from the visible and infrared light reflected from the planet's surface in the wavelength range 0.5-5.2 millimetres. As light reflected from the surface must pass through the atmosphere before entering the instrument, OMEGA will also measure aspects of atmospheric composition.

"We want to know the iron content of the surface, the water content of the rocks and clay minerals and the abundance of non-silicate materials such as carbonates and nitrates," says Jean-Pierre Bibring, OMEGA PI from the Institut d’Astrophysique Spatiale, Orsay, France.

SPICAM instrument

SPICAM Ultraviolet and Infrared Atmospheric Spectrometer

SPICAM will determine the composition of the atmosphere from the wavelengths of light absorbed by the constituent gases. An ultraviolet (UV) sensor will measure ozone, which absorbs 250-nanometre light, and an infrared (IR) sensor will measure water vapour, which absorbs 1.38 micron light.

"Over the lifetime of the mission, we should be able to build up measurements of ozone and water vapour over the total surface of the planet for the different seasons," says Jean-Loup Bertaux, SPICAM PI from the Service d'Aeronomie du CNRS, Verrières-le-Buisson, France.

Planetary Fourier Spectrometer (PFS)

The PFS will determine the composition of the Martian atmosphere from the wavelengths of sunlight (in the range 1.2-45 millimetres) absorbed by molecules in the atmosphere and from the infrared radiation they emit.

In particular, it will measure the vertical pressure and temperature profile of carbon dioxide which makes up 95% of the martian atmosphere, and look for minor constituents including water, carbon monoxide, methane and formaldehyde.

"We hope to get many, many measurements so that by taking the average of thousands we'll be able to see minor species," says Vittorio Formisano, PFS PI from Istituto Fisica Spazio Interplanetario, Rome, Italy.

ASPERA Energetic Neutral Atoms Analyser

ASPERA will measure ions, electrons and energetic neutral atoms in the outer atmosphere to reveal the numbers of oxygen and hydrogen atoms (the constituents of water) interacting with the solar wind and the regions of such interaction.

Constant bombardment by the stream of charged particles pouring out from the Sun, is thought to be responsible for the loss of Mars's atmosphere. The planet no longer has a global magnetic field to deflect the solar wind, which is consequently free to interact unhindered with atoms of atmospheric gas and sweep them out to space.

"We will be able to see this plasma escaping the planet and so estimate how much atmosphere has been lost over billions of years," says Rickard Lundin, ASPERA PI from the Swedish Institute of Space Physics in Kiruna, Sweden.

MaRS

Mars Radio Science Experiment (MaRS)

MaRS will use the radio signals that convey data and instructions between the spacecraft and Earth to probe the planet's ionosphere, atmosphere, surface and even the interior.

Information on the interior will be gleaned from the planet's gravity field, which will be calculated from changes in the velocity of the spacecraft relative to Earth. Surface roughness will be deduced from the way in which the radio waves are reflected from the Martian surface.

"Variations in the gravitational field of Mars will cause slight changes in the speed of the spacecraft relative to the ground station, which can be measured with an accuracy of less than one tenth the speed of a snail at full pace," says Martin Pätzold, MaRS PI from Köln University, Germany.

Mars Express with MARSIS antenna unfurled

MARSIS Sub-Surface Sounding Radar Altimeter

MARSIS will map the sub-surface structure to a depth of a few kilometres. The instrument's 40-metre long antenna will send low frequency radio waves towards the planet, which will be reflected from any surface they encounter.

For most, this will be the surface of Mars, but a significant fraction will travel through the crust to be reflected at sub-surface interfaces between layers of different material, including water or ice.

"We should be able to measure the thickness of sand deposits in dune areas, or determine whether there are layers of sediment sitting on top of other material," says Giovanni Picardi, MARSIS Principal Investigator from Universita di Roma 'La Sapienza', Rome, Italy. MARSIS will also study the ionosphere, as this electrically charged region of the upper atmosphere will reflect some radio waves.

32 posted on 01/04/2004 11:21:14 AM PST by e_engineer
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: mylife
Did Spirit land anywhere near Beagle2?

It would be cool if it could find Beagle2

The first color image:


33 posted on 01/04/2004 11:29:05 AM PST by Thinkin' Gal
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies]

To: Orbital Velocity
From the Department of Irreverent Humor:

      America: "The Eagle Has Landed."

      UK: "The Beagle Has Pooped."

(Actually, I hope Beagle eventually succeeds.)

34 posted on 01/04/2004 11:45:02 AM PST by jigsaw (God Bless Our Troops.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Orbital Velocity
In contrast the Beagle 2 project was put together on a shoestring by clever and inventive engineers

NASA's engineers of course substitute money for cleverness and inventiveness.

Seems like this is the first article to actually cast sour grapes at someone else's Mars program. However, by use of irony it is actually a hit piece on the European space program. The author is saying that Europe cannot afford to explore space and it is up to the Americans if we are ever going to get off this mudball.

35 posted on 01/04/2004 11:52:04 AM PST by RightWhale (Repeal the Law of the Excluded Middle)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Orbital Velocity
Beagles seems like a bad deal from an economic point of view. True it cost only a third of Spirit, but it returned nothing. That Europeans took a gamble. High risk for high return. In this case the gamble didn't work. If the Europeans want to succeed over the long term, they can't run their space programs like a crap game. They have to adjust their strategy so that the expected value, not the windfall, is the driving design spec.
36 posted on 01/04/2004 12:02:43 PM PST by wretchard
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Beagle 2, the brainchild of Professor Colin Pillinger, has no built-in redundancy.

Somewhere there's a child missing a brain.

37 posted on 01/04/2004 12:14:37 PM PST by D-fendr
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 36 | View Replies]

To: D-fendr
Yup. Redundancy is a blessing not to be taken lightly.
38 posted on 01/04/2004 1:28:15 PM PST by Chewbacca (I talk to myself because it is the only way I can have an intelligent conversation.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 37 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-38 last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson