[Woahhs]

There is no difference to a child between a time out chair and a bedroom. If I put her in a time out chair, she gets up and walks back to the rest of the family to scream....and if she throws the door open and walks out, what does she learn?

Obviously, your definition of "works" is much different from mine.

[netmilsmom]

Yes, I would say.
However, I can take my children anywhere and they behave. I fall asleep with them every night and get big kisses from them every morning. As I said, each has had a swat one time. We read every night and play every day. You are more than welcome to be judgemental, but until you sit in my shoes, and have a better suggestion, you can't really say anything.