[Just another Joe]

Again, the punishment does not fit the situation.

Resign and no retirement? I wouldn't have taken it. Would you?

Non-judicial punishment, IMO, would have been the way to go.
It could have been more than an a$$ chewing and discipline would have been maintained.

[Ispy4u]

Given the severity of the charges, I'm not sure if NJP was an available option. That's why I'm not willing to attack the DIV CG or the JAG for their offer.