Replies

Okay, well, if these people this Carroll talks about did it (if these people even exist, which I'm not sure they do), that theory still goes back to an origination point of SCOTT. I'm not talking about the legal implications here, necessarily, I'm just saying that the Carroll stuff can't be entertained w/o having Scott enter the picture regarding his wife's death. Of course, the Carroll story can be told in several different ways, with differing levels of culpability for Scott in each version.

Second: Kim McGregor? She does seem like a real wacko, but when we get to the fact that Laci was taken 90 miles to SF Bay... I don't think Kim could stay sober long enough to carry out all that.

I'm not inclined to try to make arguments that either scenario I presented as hypotheticals actually happened. I was only trying to answer the questions you posed. Such scenarios are, in my mind's eye, possible--not probable but possible, if defense wants to throw it out there for jury consideration.