[r9etb]

The American Soldiers did not testify that she beat the prisoner!

According to the article:

Fellow soldiers testified that the four Pennsylvania reservists punched and kicked prisoners who were being brought to an American camp in southern Iraq on May 12. One prisoner suffered a broken nose.

So you might want to revise your opinion.

Unless perhaps you'll next be trying to tell us that punching and kicking do not qualify as "beating," at least not when "it's war?"

[ConservativeMan55]

"Fellow soldiers testified that the four Pennsylvania reservists punched and kicked prisoners who were being brought to an American camp in southern Iraq on May 12. One prisoner suffered a broken nose."

Where does it say anything about the actions of the prisoner? Unless you can cite that you are wrong.

[Eagle Eye]

YOU said it was unprovoked.

SHE said it was self defense.

YOU said it was unprovoked.

YOU called her claim a lie.

YOU took sides against the enemy and willingly told fibs to do it.

Shawna can watch my back any day. At least she has some guts.