[Ispy4u]

They probably wouldn't.

But they also have been trained to adjust operations to counter expected ambushes and deal with that threat head on. That is what we do.

There is nothing new or unique about an ambush. The troops had a tactical advantage knowing in advance that one was being planned. The leaders of the unit, including LTC West, should have the knowledge and resources available to them to thwart the plan within the already set parameters of the mission.

He chose a different method and even though his troops may admire that, the problem will come when they have to counter a planned ambush and wonder why their new commander didn't just round up some more hajjis and scare the info out of them.

The whole episode is a breeding ground for dissent and indiscipline, the very things the rules are in place to avoid.

[Pukin Dog]

He chose a different method and even though his troops may admire that"

Not only did his troops NOT admire that, they turned him in. Col. West's followers would like you to believe that he reported on himself, which is false. Not only that, Col. West punished his own men for their own code violations prior to his incident. But you are right to say that Col. West CHOSE another method. He had no right to choose anything outside of the rules he swore to follow.

[William Terrell]

Have you taken a poll of mudfeet over there to see what they think about the incident, or are you just projecting from the comfort and safety of your armchair?