Madison was for voluntary colonization. (pro-liberty)
Lincolon - Involuntary. (that's anti-liberty)
"The slaves themselves, connected, as they generally are, by tender ties with others under other masters, would be kept from the list of emigrants by the want of the multiplied consents to be obtained. "
http://www.jmu.edu/madison/emancslaves.htm
Lincoln was for voluntary colonization. I'm not aware of anyone who ever expressed a preference for forced deportation, except Jefferson Davis.