[JohnGalt]

When was I asked that? As written that is a perfectly legitimate position in 2003 America.

It's the belief that American is struck by natural disasters when Israel is slighted that is an unpatriotic position; it's equivalent to Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell blaming American culture for 9/11.

You may call it Christian and patriotic, I call it heretical and un-patriotic. The debate, I believe is worthwhile and should be conducted out in the open.