`Shooting the bird' rude, crude but legal - Appeals court overturns conviction

Houston Chronicle ^ | October 15, 2003 | THOM MARSHALL

[Cincinatus' Wife]

Using the hand signal rooted in ancient times and popularly known today as "shooting the bird" may be rude, but it's not necessarily disorderly conduct, a Texas appeals court has ruled.

At issue for the 3rd Court of Appeals in Austin was whether Robert Lee Coggin incited "an immediate breach of the peace" when he allegedly gestured at a motorist with his raised middle finger two years ago as the former Lockhart resident tailgated a slow-moving vehicle in the left lane of U.S. 183.

Coggin was charged under an obscure state law that says "a person commits an offense if he intentionally or knowingly makes an offensive gesture or display in a public place, and the gesture or display tends to incite an immediate breach of the peace."

A jury last year convicted Coggin, 34, and fined him $250 for making "an offensive gesture by raising his middle finger in a public place," a finding that the appeals court reversed.

Coggin, an electrical engineer who now lives in Austin, denies he made the gesture, and, on the advice of his wife and a friend who urged him to "do what you got to do," spent $15,000 on attorney fees in pursuit of justice.

The quirky saga began in October 2001 on Colorado Street in Lockhart, which also is U.S. 183. Coggin, driving a souped-up Chevrolet Caprice that once did service as a police unit, came upon a vehicle driven by John Pastrano, a Caldwell County jailer. Coggin followed Pastrano's car closely, flashed his lights and motioned for the vehicle to move to the right lane.

Pastrano, thinking he was being stopped by a police car, move into the right lane, court records show. As Coggin passed Pastrano, he allegedly gestured with his raised middle finger.

Pastrano testified later that the incident angered him and he called 911. Lockhart police stopped Coggin and, after conferring with Pastrano, who was called to the scene by the dispatcher, wrote Coggin a ticket for the Class C misdemeanor of "disorderly conduct -- gesture."

Pastrano, 24, who now works for the Hays County Sheriff's Department in San Marcos, could not be reached Tuesday for comment.

Chief Justice Kenneth Law wrote in his dissenting opinion that the case did have "all of the ingredients for immediate violence" and that "one must ignore the reality of modern life to not recognize that many instances of `road rage' begin in such a manner."

His colleagues on the 3rd Court disagreed, noting "the evidence was legally insufficient to establish that (Coggin's) gesture tends to incite an immediate breach of the peace." They reversed the conviction and ordered acquittal.

But the court didn't stop there, offering context and history to the episode.

The court's majority opinion, filed Thursday, quoted a Merriam-Webster OnLine definition of the "bird" as "an obscene gesture of contempt made by pointing the middle finger up while keeping the other fingers down."

The jurists further explained that "the middle finger jerk was so popular among the Romans that they even gave a special name to the middle digit, calling it the impudent finger: digitus impudicus.

"It was also known as the obscene finger, or the infamous finger, and there are a number of references to its use in the writings of classical authors. ... " the jurists continued. "The middle-finger jerk has survived for over 2,000 years and is still current in many parts of the world, especially in the United States."

Coggin said he felt exonerated and doesn't regret spending the money.

"It vindicates me," he said.

[stands2reason]

O-kaaaaaaaay....

[Support Free Republic]

The Free Republic Lifeform

"... This is a wonderful description of what Free Republic really is. It is a living and evolving Life Form to battle the left wingers and those who would destroy this country!

The Free Republic Life Form enables us to discover the truth about what is happening. We can avoid the spin of the major mediots as they work 24/7 to weaken this country. We come to the Free Republic Life Form to find the truth! ...

Free Republic needs a constant infusion of cash to keep the Free Republic Life Form alive, viable and to grow. If we believe in Free Republic, we must donate each month or quarterly to keep this incredible life form alive...

Good stewardship is what this world needs, not good intentions. Good conservative stewards will insure that the Free Republic Life Form continues to grow, be viable and thrives!"

Thank You for your support!

Click The Logo To Donate

Or mail checks to

FreeRepublic , LLC
PO BOX 9771
FRESNO, CA 93794

or you can use

PayPal at Jimrob@psnw.com

[Neanderthal]

Jerks who drive slowly in the left (passing) lane deserve the bird.

[Graybeard58]

In 1975 I had the middle finger of my left hand amputated in an industrial accident, This is a tremendous handicap while driving, It is very awkward to stick my right hand out the drivers window to "shoot the bird" I have tried using the ring finger and all I get is comments like, "Nice wedding band buddy" if I stick out my pinky finger they think I am gay. if I use the index finger people just think I am pointing at them. Everybody knows that an upraised thumb is the "OK" sign.
...In addition I can't use drive through windows at fast food places - The change just slips through my left hand and falls to the ground. If I open the door to reach out and retrieve the change I get drivers behind me honking at me to tell me to quit screwin' around and I can't even flip 'em off properly.
...At the very least I think I should be eligible for handicapped license plates but the license bureau has denied my request repeatedly. Life's a bitch aint it?

[Major_Risktaker]

"spent $15,000 on attorney fees in pursuit of justice."

$15,000 for his day in court over this matter is crazy.
The cost of justice is to high like medical cost.

[Cincinatus' Wife]

Life's a bitch aint it?

Well, if one had to go, it was better than the thumb!

[Cincinatus' Wife]

I don't see a sympathetic person in the whole story.

[BJungNan]

How does a stupid case like this take up the courts time. The first judge should have thrown it out. My gosh, what would they do in New York? Even the bank tellers there flip you off if you get testy with them.

[JoeSixPack1]

"Horn Broke, Watch for Finger" <---- one bumper sticker you can't use.

:-)~~

[Cincinatus' Wife]

You know, your post reminds me of something I saw on a train. There was a man with no arms smoking a cigarette with his toes.

[Cincinatus' Wife]

My gosh, what would they do in New York? Even the bank tellers there flip you off if you get testy with them.

And I'm sure they don't try to deny it.

[G.Mason]

"I don't see a sympathetic person in the whole story."

I do. The tax payers who had to foot the bill for the original charges.

" Pastrano, 24, who now works for the Hays County Sheriff's Department in San Marcos, could not be reached Tuesday for comment."

And now the idiot who filed the charges is possibly a cop?

That's comforting.

[Cincinatus' Wife]

Ah.....yes, the forgotten taxpayer.

[PBRSTREETGANG]

[PBRSTREETGANG]

[Dog Gone]

Pastrano testified later that the incident angered him and he called 911.

"Somebody flipped me off!!! Waaa! Send the cops! It's an emergency!! Lights and sirens! Waaa!!!!"

[Cincinatus' Wife]

I hope he catches a lot criticism - actually both of them should.

[Piquaboy]

I must be old! I use to think that shooting the bird was when someone asked me to go Quail hunting with them.

[Cincinatus' Wife]

You're old.