I do not think any relief is due (or good for the national fisc) for anyone who has not lost their job since March 2020, nor any social security recipient, nor any other retired person whose retirement income loss, if any, was greater than their social security income.
If relief is needed it is only needed for persons whose incomes were actually GREATLY impacted by the economic shutdowns and ramifications through the economy due to them.
Everyone in the general public who kept their jobs and otherwise most of their income is not deserving of any “stimulus” in my opinion.
I get out a lot in my local economy. I figure it is my obligation as a retired person with zero financial loss during the “pandemic” to get out and help keep my local merchants in business. I don’t think our grand children, great grand children and others should be made giant debtors to help out our economy now. The pieces should be picked up now by everyone whose incomes have not taken a hit.
I’m not retired but I do the same thing in my community.
The local merchants love seeing me walk in their doors. All of them, both big and small need customers.
Yes, I’m with you, though I’d include those looking for work in March 2020 and freelance/gig workers who lost income that is not as easily demonstrated as the regular unemployed.