Posted on 08/27/2023 6:29:24 AM PDT by marktwain
We are hiking at Waterton, Glacier, and Yellowstone next week. We saw a big bruin up close at Glacier in 2020. I had left the bear spray in the car. He was polite, though.
They didn’t count the people who thought it worked like bug spray ...
... and the people it didn’t work for at all never got back to them for some reason.
I’m pro-gun, but I switched from a sidearm to carrying bear spray years ago. It just makes sense - I’d rather have what is effectively a small flamethrower than be trying to hit the brain case of a charging grizzly with my .40 S&W.
That is the illusion which is sold.
Unfortunately, bear spray has many limitations, itself. It does not work well in cold temps, or wind at almost any velocity. It does not penetrate foliage. While I have not seen any tests, It is likely much diminished in rain. Many bears are able to shrug it off or ignore it, especially black bears, or any bears in a predatory mode.
Fortunately, with handguns, you don't have to hit the brain case in every instance.
When it happens, it works very well. But in most cases, it is not necessary.
Bears often break off their aggressive action because of warning shots.
A great number of aggressive bears do not start with a full on charge.
Lots of bears break off the attack if wounded.
Wounding a bear often slows them down enough to get killing shots into them.
Often, the person shooting the bear is someone the bear did not target.
Handguns are far more ergonomic,and have far better holsters than bear spray.
All of those add up to 98% effective for handguns when the handguns are fired.
how can it possibly be that there were more people injured in instances with injury than total people injured? Are they disregarding cases where the same guy is repeatedly bullied by a conspiracy of bears?
That could be just a transportation problem.
They manipulated the numbers.
To show that spray works better then firearms.
No it does not make sense to use spray instead of a firearm.
The anti-pro bear propaganda worked well on you.
Spray has a lot of limitations most caused by mother nature.
It is called weather. Then there is just limitation of range.
If you are not a good enough shot. Get some professional training and practice some more.
As a professional firearms instructor.
I offer a bear and animal defense training.
Could be. Most of the ones I have talked to, however, are uncomfortable (To put it mildly) with the very idea of people carrying firearms. If they only knew...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.