American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part II)

FOX ^ | 3-25-06

[kevkrom]

"Unchained Melody" done with a Country Western style is amazing! The Pickler can pull it off.

Not even close.

[kevkrom]

I think if Kellie had training she'd be fabulous.

I agree, assuming that by "training" you mean that she can be taught to fetch me a beer while I listen to someone else sing.

[kevkrom]

Did anybody else notice that McPhee had an extremely embarrassing pantie line tonight?

No... for some odd reason, my eyes were drawn higher that that...

[kevkrom]

Taylor is doing pretty good in my opinion.....better than the pickle....

Oh, like that's hard.

[Netizen]

Dial Idol's final numbers for last night:

DialIdol
Rank

Idol

DialIdol Score

Margin Of Error

Actual Rank

1-3

Taylor Hicks 05

26.01

1.581

-

1-3

Chris Daughtry 06

25.954

1.582

-

1-4

(B3)

Elliott Yamin 02

23.721

1.605

-

3-5

(B3)

Katharine McPhee 01

22.467

1.619

-

4-6

(B3)

Kellie Pickler 03

19.421

1.65

-

5-6

(B3)

Paris Bennett 04

17.36

1.671

-

Not sure how accurate they will be considering that they were monitoring the first set of phone numbers.

[kevkrom]

WHOA!!!! McPhee's boobs are on FULL display!! :)

I was hoping to see vidcaps on the thread this morning... :(

[kevkrom]

BTW... Mrs. kevkrom made a good observation that we would have gotten better performances from both Kat and Paris if they had switched songs...

[silent_jonny]

A shame, but I expect Paris to get voted off this week. Just don't think she has the dedicated fan base necessary to save her.

I think you're right. But Pickler's fan base is eroding--if she's not gone tonight, then hopefully she's next.

[silent_jonny]

Mornin', Hetty :)

I vote Elliott "Most Improved."

I agree. And he improves consistently week after week. I don't think we've seen (or heard) him go backwards once during the competition. He keeps pushing forward.

(Gherkin) going for that high note was NOT the best choice

Whew .... That whole song was a bad choice :o

(I was tickled to see Chris singing from the floor -- I've been there! LOL!)

:)

[silent_jonny]

working with Manilow, Stewart, and now Foster is really starting to tech him how to perform instead of just sing.

That's another thing I admire about Elliot. Where the others might just ham it up with the guests (Pickler), he sincerely makes an effort to absorb their knowledge and use it. And he's used it effectively. Good job.

[silent_jonny]

I was hoping to see vidcaps on the thread this morning... :(

How about these--I mean this? ;)

[silent_jonny]

With all the talk about McPhee's visible pantie line, no one mentioned that she actually had visible panties!

[silent_jonny]

Sheesh--you weren't kidding about Whitney Houston.

[AnnaZ]

Yikes! Okay, I ditch the "ditch the panties" comment. They should have been different ones then, or at least pulled up to her waist.

Again, yikes! Now that would have made headlines. Janet Jackson who?

[maggief]

Morning, jonny!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yep, she's no Whitney Houston all right.

What a waste!

[kevkrom]

You are a good, good man.

[Senator Goldwater]

Thanks for producing that web gem. I just came from the DVR, and found the pantie shot at the "don't you dare" refrain [ironically].

Apparently a button came loose during an earlier move, and it allowed the front part to sweep open when she walked forward. Gloriiusly for all of us, the stage right camera caught the promised land.

[gopheraj]

LOLL Hubby just saw your post/pics. Said he wished he hadn't taken a pre-bed nap. LOLL Her panties ended up showing because every time she did that bend/squat down at the knees thingy, she would pop open a button or two. Saw a couple pop as I watched.

[retrokitten]

Darn it. You left an hour and a half ago, but good night, RK :)

Real life was calling. Stupid real life! :-D

[Apple Blossom]

If there is a guy in the bottom three, and that's a big IF, it should be Taylor. The song was a star as David Foster put it, but it wasn't sung well.