Posted on 11/20/2026 1:04:00 PM PST by SunkenCiv
SpaceX's Ship 42 is home, and now the real work starts. One Starship heat shield tile out of 18,000 failed on the way down. So why didn't that hurt the ship at all? Why is a steel rocket suddenly covered in rainbow colors? The tower arms scraped black dust off the hull during the catch, and the fix is a NASA idea from 1974 that started inside a helicopter. Elon Musk says the next Starship v4 upper stage will be as tall as an entire Falcon 9, and that filling up the whole rocket will cost less than a nice house. How is that even possible? And where will the next Starship launch from, Texas or Florida?
Musk Just Revealed Starship V4, and It Changes Everything | 24:27
What about it!? | 678K subscribers | 220,299 views | November 20, 2026
(Excerpt) Read more at youtube.com ...
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
0:00 The Aftermath of a Historic Catch
2:04 Decoding the Rainbow Hull
3:10 The Truth About the Damaged Tile
7:59 The Secret History of Metal Wool
14:18 The Economics of Full Reuse
18:11 The Massive Scale of Starship V4
The YouTube transcript was processed with my fine country craftsmanship, and *may* follow.
ULA Gives Update on Total Mission Loss...
9:21
Ellie in Space
233K subscribers
November 20, 2026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2hPmOv7KlSo
https://www.youtube.com/@ellieinspace/videos
🚀🛰️
Transcript
Chapter 1: The Aftermath of a Historic Catch
Ship 42 is home, and now the real work starts. One heat shield tile out of 18,000 failed on the way down. So why didn’t that hurt the ship at all? Why is a steel rocket suddenly covered in rainbow colors? The tower arms scraped black dust off the hull during the catch, and the fix is a NASA idea from 1974 that started inside a helicopter. Elon Musk says the next Starship upper stage will be as tall as an entire Falcon 9, and that filling up the whole rocket will cost less than a nice house. How is that even possible? And where will the next Starship launch from, Texas or Florida?
My name is Felix. Welcome to What About It!? Let’s dive right in!
Starship Updates SpaceX caught a Starship from orbit. It changed everything. That was last Saturday. So what do you do with a spaceship that just came home? You go and look at it. Very closely.
Right after the catch, Elon Musk went up on a boom lift and inspected Ship 42 himself. He filmed it from below, with the ship still hanging in the chopsticks.
Then he showed up on the ship quick disconnect arm. That’s the arm that feeds propellant into the ship before launch. You could even spot him on the remote cameras. Trillionaire for scale.
Then he went all the way to the top of Mechazilla and filmed down along the ship with his phone. He even hugged it. I get it. I would have hugged it too. His first verdict: Ship 42 looks great!
A day later, he was back at the pad and went over the whole heat shield. Overall it looks great, he says, and the engines do too. Ship 42 could probably fly again after a few weeks of refurbishment. But a few weeks is not the goal. The goal is an airplane. Land, refuel, fly, with nothing but scheduled maintenance. To get there, Musk says many small fixes are needed. Today, we look at three of them. They are written right on the hull. All right, let’s start with the pretty one.
Chapter 2: Decoding the Rainbow Hull
Have you seen the colors on Ship 42? Gold, brown, purple, and blue, all over the steel. Starship left Texas silver and came back looking like... a motorcycle exhaust! That’s exactly what it is. When stainless steel gets hot in air, a very thin oxide layer grows on its surface. Light bounces around inside that layer, and we see a color. The steel isn’t dyed, and it isn’t burned. It’s the same trick that puts colors on a soap bubble. The fun part: the thickness of that layer depends on the temperature. So the color tells you how hot the steel got. Pale straw means roughly 300° C. Purple and blue mean closer to 500 or 600.
So the whole ship is now a temperature map. Every stripe tells the engineers where the heat went, and that goes straight into the next design. My friend Joe Tegtmeyer collaborated on the research with me. He explained this beautifully on X this week. Go read it. Link is in the description. And not everything on that hull is pretty, though. There’s one spot everybody is talking about.
Chapter 3: The Truth About the Damaged Tile
Jordan caught it on camera for us. A single damaged tile on the belly of Ship 42, and below it, a long orange streak. First, let’s clear something up. This was not one of the metal test tiles, as some reported. It was a standard Starship tile. One out of about 18,000. So what are we looking at? A Starship tile has two parts. The body is a white, porous block of silica, basically very pure sand, baked into something that is mostly air. It’s soft. Scrape it, and it turns into white dust. So here, scrape, scrape, scrape, scrape, scrape, scrape. And then you have this white stuff on the finger. It’s.. It’s really like There it is. See?
Ah, I have a few of them here in the studio. On top sits a thin black glaze. It has this black glassy layer on the other side. Protection. SpaceX has never published the recipe. But these tiles are very similar to the ones on the Space Shuttle, and there, the black layer was a special kind of glass. The black skin has a job. It sheds heat. Around 90% of what hits it gets radiated right back out. The white stuff underneath only keeps what’s left from reaching the steel.
On this particular tile on Ship 42, the black skin is gone. Peeled off and eaten away by the plasma. You can still see the white silica sitting in the damaged part. So the tile did not fall off. It lost its upper layer. So, what about the orange streak? That’s oxidized steel, blown downstream by the flow. My guess: it comes from the tile’s own mounting pins. Once the glaze was gone, heat got in, the steel under the tile got much hotter than planned, and the airflow painted the result all over the tiles below. Those tiles started showing the same damage. That’s the nasty part of any heat shield. Give the heat one way in, and it keeps digging.
But now look at the ship. It flew its reentry, flipped, and landed in the chopsticks as if nothing had happened. Why? The Space Shuttle was built from aluminum. Aluminum gets weak at around 175° C and it melts at 660. So the Shuttle’s heat shield had to be perfect. Every single flight. In 2003, a piece of foam punched a hole into the leading edge of Columbia’s wing during launch. On the way home, hot gas got inside, the aluminum structure failed, and seven astronauts died. There’s a second Shuttle story, and it’s less well known. In 1988, Atlantis came home with more than 700 damaged tiles. One was missing completely. The crew survived because of pure luck.
Right under the missing tile sat the thick mounting plate of an antenna. Anywhere else, there would have been thin aluminum skin. A lucky piece of extra metal saved Atlantis. Starship doesn’t need luck. Its stainless steel melts at around 1,400°. It stays strong at temperatures where aluminum is already soft. So when one tile fails, the ship gets a scar and an orange stripe. The Shuttle would have been in serious trouble. SpaceX still has to fix it. A tile that fails means work before the next flight, and work is the enemy of an airplane. But it shows why building a spaceship out of steel was such a good idea.
[ad text redacted]
Back to Ship 42, and to the moment the tower grabbed it.
Chapter 4: The Secret History of Metal Wool
SpaceX released close-up views of the catch from Mechazilla itself. Watch the arms. As they close, they rub along the hull, right over the black heat protection that frames the tiles on what. As they get close, they rub along the hull, right over the black heat protection that frames the tiles on the leeward side. That material is ablative. It is made to char and wear away. After reentry, it’s heavily carbonized, and when the chopsticks scrub over it, it simply turns into black dust. That doesn’t look very reusable, right? Correct. It isn’t. Musk answered that one too. This black material is a placeholder. On future flights, it will be replaced with stainless steel wool. Wait. Steel wool? The stuff you clean pans with? Not quite.
I dug into this together with Joe Tegtmeyer. Thank you, Joe! We ended up in the NASA archives, and what we found there is a great story. In March 1974, a report landed at NASA’s Langley Research Center. The title: Metal-Wool Heat Shields for Space Shuttle. The authors didn’t work for a rocket company. They worked for Hughes Helicopters in California. Why would helicopter people design a heat shield? Because they had worked on a very strange helicopter. No drive shaft to the rotor. Instead, jet engine exhaust at about 600° C was blown through the rotor blades and out at the tips. That’s what turned the rotor.
So they needed insulation that survives hot gas, vibration, and brutal g-forces inside a spinning blade. Their answer was a pad of very fine stainless steel fibers. It works kind of like a wool sweater. The fibers themselves hardly matter. They break the space up into tiny pockets, and heat has a hard time getting through. Take the air away, and it gets even better. In vacuum, the report says, the heat flow drops by about a factor of three. For the Shuttle, Hughes packaged that wool. Look at the drawings. On the outside, a skin of stainless steel foil, about as thin as the foil in your kitchen, corrugated so it can grow and shrink with the heat. Inside, the wool. Underneath, thin supports.
The report suggests cutting holes into them near the hot end, so less heat can sneak down into the structure. They built seven test pieces, five inches square and one inch thick, and sent them to NASA’s arc jet. The whole package was about half as dense as a Shuttle tile. Good to about 540° C and up to almost 1,000 under the right conditions. Now compare that with a ceramic tile. Metal wool doesn’t crack. It doesn’t shatter when something hits it. It can be squeezed, and it’s still there afterwards. Exactly what you want at the spot where two giant steel arms grab your spaceship. But the Shuttle went with the ceramic tiles, and the metal wool went into the archive.
There’s a detail Joe and I almost missed. The last drawing in our stack isn’t from the 1974 report at all. It’s from a follow-up that Hughes delivered two years later, for a hypersonic aircraft flying at Mach 8. That report has a warning in it. The engineers held a match to very fine stainless steel wool in a stream of air. It caught fire and kept burning. Stainless steel, burning? Yes. If the fibers are fine enough. Their rule: fibers thinner than 25 microns, about a third of a human hair, should stay out of hot, fast air unless they’re well packaged. Thicker fibers didn’t burn. That’s why the follow-up shows three versions: classic wool, a knit of thicker wire, and expanded metal foil, each with thin foil layers that reflect heat. They also shot rain and sand at the skin at more than 500 km/h. It came out far better than the non-metallic insulation of the day.
One more thing made me smile. To help the outer skin get rid of heat, the engineers oxidized it on purpose. Reentry just did the same to Ship 42 for free. That’s our rainbow from earlier. So when Musk says steel wool, don’t picture a kitchen sponge glued to a rocket. Picture a thin metal package with the right fibers inside. How SpaceX will build its version, we don’t know yet. Or do we? Look at this. Jordan photographed the aft flap of Ship 42 after the catch. On the bare steel side, right next to the tiles, sits a rectangular patch. Flat, but not flush with the flap. It has a frame around it, and its face shows rows of tiny marks, as if some structure inside is attached to the skin. Remember the 1974 drawings? A thin steel skin, welded in rows to the support underneath, with the wool in between. This patch even shows the same heat colors as the steel around it.
There’s a second one as well higher up on the other aft flap, right next to the three test tiles. This one looks different. It comes in two halves, and its surface has a fine ribbed texture, almost like a fabric made of metal. Two patches, two different surfaces. That’s how you test two versions of the same idea. The aft flaps are where SpaceX likes to fly test patches and test tiles. So are these the first pieces of metal wool that have been to orbit and back? I can’t prove it. But I wouldn’t be surprised.
[channel plug redacted]
Now, Ship 42 only got its chance because of a decision SpaceX made one flight earlier. We finally get to see it.
Chapter 5: The Economics of Full Reuse
SpaceX released episode 4 of its Starship documentary, Go For Orbit. It’s about Flight 14, and it has a scene I didn’t expect. When one engine shut down on the way up, the rule said: no orbit. The ship goes into the Indian Ocean, satellites and all. Then Musk asked if anything really prohibits going on. The engine team checked, the hold was lifted, and Starship went to orbit. That is SpaceX. Two more gems. Ship 41 flew two tiles that SpaceX had pulled off Ship 40, the first reflown Starship tiles ever. At the very end, the flight director polls every station: would this ship be go to return to the launch site? All of them say go.
Not even seven weeks later, they did it for real. So what does that catch mean in dollars? SpaceX’s money man has an answer. On Tuesday, SpaceX CFO Bret Johnsen sat down with investor Gavin Baker at the TomorrowX Summit in Austin. He called Flight 15 a critical milestone, years in the making. SpaceX has brought back first stages many times, he said. But nobody has ever brought back a second stage that had already delivered 26 satellites to orbit. In the old world, that alone would be mission accomplished.
Then came the number. Full reuse means another ten times improvement in cost per kilogram to space. Johnsen called it “the holy grail of rocketry”. You fly, and all you pay for is the fuel and a little bit of operations. He also said what SpaceX wants to do with that: orbital compute. Data centers in space. Remember StarMind from October? Johnsen’s timeline: first satellites next year, the constellation grows in 2028, serious amounts of compute in orbit in 2029. In a year or two, he expects it to become cheaper than building the same thing on the ground. No power bill, no cooling, no land.
Baker had some advice too. If you have kids or grandkids, take them to a Starship launch. He says about half of the adults cry. Yeah, I can confirm that. I’m one of them. Fuel and a little bit of operations. So how much is the fuel? After the catch, someone posted that it costs about a million dollars to fuel a Starship. I said $800,000 on the live stream. Musk corrected that. Propellant cost per flight will drop below $500,000 and payload will exceed 200 tons.
Let that sink in. A Starship stack takes more than 5,000 tons of liquid oxygen and liquid methane. For half a million dollars, that is about 10 cents per kilo. Cheaper than bottled water. How? Most of the load is oxygen, and oxygen is made from air. All you need is electricity and a big plant, and SpaceX is building its own. The rest is methane. Natural gas, cleaned up and chilled.
Now, let’s divide. Let’s do the math. $500,000 for 200 tons of payload is $2.50 per kilo to orbit. Fuel only, of course. Compare that with Falcon 9. Its fuel bill is even smaller, a few hundred thousand dollars. But a launch still costs SpaceX around 15 million, even with a reused booster, mainly because the second stage is built new and thrown away every time. That is roughly $900 per kilo.
This is the essence of why you reuse as much of a vehicle as you can. Think of an airliner. Nobody throws away the plane after one flight to New York. You pay for the fuel, the crew, the airport, and maintenance. If you can reuse the whole rocket with little maintenance, you’re left with ground operations and the fuel bill. 200 tons, though? The Starship that just flew can’t do that. The next one can, though.
Chapter 6: The Massive Scale of Starship V4
The day after the catch, Musk laid it out. Starship V4 will be about 70 m tall. That is roughly 40% taller than Ship 42. It will hold more than 60% more propellant. It gets nine engines instead of six, with three more vacuum Raptors, and those will be new V4 engines with more thrust. 70 m. That is the height of an entire Falcon 9, both stages and the fairing. This is only the upper stage!
Elliot built it for us at scale right next to a v3 Starship. As a comparison, the Saturn V Moon rocket was 111. Come on!If the booster stays as it is, the whole stack grows from 124 meters to more than 140. As a comparison, the Saturn V Moon rocket was 111. More than 60% more propellant means well over 2,500 tons in the Ship alone. Today’s Ship holds about, today’s Ship holds about 1,600. So what does that change?
Why nine engines? Because a ship that carries 60% more propellant is a lot heavier at staging. With only six engines, it would climb too slowly and waste propellant just fighting gravity. Three more vacuum engines fix that. That makes six vacuum Raptors and three sea-level Raptors in the middle for steering and landing. More payload. Today’s V3 is good for about a 100 tons to orbit. V4 aims for more than 200.
And what does that mean for Starlink? Flight 15 carried 26 V3 satellites, each good for one terabit per second. That was a test load. A full V3 Starship is supposed to carry around 60 of them. That fits what Musk posted: future flights will carry more than 50 terabits per second. Now double the payload. My math: V4 could lift well over 100 of these satellites, if they fit into the bay. More than 100 terabits per second on a single launch.
A Falcon 9 with today’s smaller satellites brings about two and a half. So one V4 Starship would do the work of roughly 40 Falcon 9 launches. Is it better for refueling in orbit as well? This is where it gets really interesting. A tanker’s payload is propellant. Double the payload, and you need about half as many tanker flights to fill a ship that’s waiting in orbit. Fewer tanker flights mean less waiting in orbit, and less time for propellant to boil away. That’s a big deal for every mission that needs a full tank up there, like NASA’s Moon lander.
Then there’s the question many of you asked. Can the towers handle it? Some of it, yes. The Gigabay is built for vehicles up to 81 m tall. SpaceX planned ahead. If the booster keeps its height, the bottom of the ship stays where it is today, so the ship quick disconnect arm still fits. What about the chopsticks? A V4 ship sticks out almost 18 m higher. Do the arms have to reach higher to stack it? Not necessarily. The catch pins could simply sit at the same height as today, further down from the nose. A returning Starship is bottom-heavy. The engines and the plumbing sit at the very bottom, and the tanks are almost empty. As long as the pins are above the center of mass, the ship hangs stable.
What about the weight? V4 adds a few more steel rings and three more engines. That shouldn’t make a big difference. The arms are built to catch boosters too, and an empty booster is a lot heavier than an empty ship. So, after all of that, when can we see the next Starship fly? Let’s start with what has to be fixed. Booster 22 didn’t make it back to the tower. It was slightly low on fuel, because the engines underperformed a little. The fix is small: better engine consistency with Raptor 3.2, and engine cutoff about one second earlier on the way up. The last one is even just a software change.
Musk says the next booster is almost ready to fly. So Flight 16 doesn’t have to wait for hardware. The question is where it flies. NASA’s Starship has the first launch from Florida in the last quarter of this year. Pad 39A at the Kennedy Space Center. The pad of Apollo 11. And then, how will we know? Watch the barge. Every Starship that launches from Florida in the near future is built in Texas and travels by sea. The barge for that job is called You’ll Thank Me Later. Best name in the fleet. It’s 79 m long, and the trip across the Gulf takes several days. If that barge shows up in Brownsville and leaves with a booster and a ship on deck, we can be sure the next launch happens at the Kennedy Space Center.
In Florida, the vehicles still have to be checked, rolled to 39A, tanked, and test-fired. If it stays empty in the next days, Flight 16 flies from Starbase again. Pad 2 needed 46 days between Flight 14 and Flight 15. The same pace puts the next Texas launch at the very end of December. So then, what about Ship 42 itself? It’s off the tower, and SpaceX has two flown ships to study now. Ship 40 came out of the ocean. Ship 42 came home dry.
Gwynne Shotwell wants to refly a ship by early next year. Musk says this one could do it after a few weeks of work. Either way, the list for the coming months is wild. A booster catch with the new design. The first Starship in Florida. The first reflight of a ship early next year. Then two ships meeting in orbit to transfer propellant.
So, would you fly Ship 42 again, or put it in a museum right now? Tell me in the comments! And that’s it for today! Smash that like button. Subscribe for more! This is what fuels the Algorithm! And this is how you can help us for free! Check out our epic shirts in your favorite space nerd store! Our all-time favorite Raptor Engine design, and countless others, are there for you to explore! Click the card or the US or worldwide links in the description! History is being written in real time. If you want to catch the other historic stories from recent weeks, click the video on screen and continue the journey now. Thank you for wat ching, and I’ll see you again in the next episode!
I thought the black dust was from those big rectangular friction pads that gripped the outer surfaces when the vessel came to rest. I assumed it was the friction material frangeing off.
During the NASA era, it was about $100K per kilo. And that was dollars that are worth about four times as much as today.
So Musk has cut the cost to Earth orbit by a factor of 400.
That's a revolutionary change. Similar to what happened to the cost of physical work after the invention of the steam turbine, and electricity, combined. That means Musk is as much a revolutionary mind as Michael Faraday and Charles Parsons combined. Throw in James Watt and Isambard Kingdom Brunel for good measure.
Thank you for the transcripts.
It changed me into a newt.
I got better.
Will it change my sheets...?
And yet Democrats still demonize him because he DOGEd some of their favorite scams.
Now he’s got to figure out whether he can work with Blue Texas or move elsewhere. He bet heavily - and lost.
Yes, clickbait changes everything.
I can’t wait to see the stainless steel “wool” fix to the heat shield problem. Should be interesting.
4 more engines and he could put the whole earth into space/s
IMO, Musk is the 21st Century equivalent of Henry Ford.
Just as Ford reduced the cost of automobile ownership to be within reach of the common man, Must is doing the same thing for space travel.
I can think of a couple countries that would be delighted to have him set up shop.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.