THERE ARE NO PENUMBRAS!!!!!
Until Griswold is overturned, it's in their ruling opinion.
I'm stuck here. We have the nbC crowd who love citing SCOTUS rulings over Federalist essay, and here is the "landmark" SCOTUS ruling that defined the concept of "penumbras, formed by emanations."
Based on what I've been told by the nbC opponents, if it's in the SCOTUS ruling then it's the interpretation of the Constitution.
Therefore, penumbras, formed by emanations of the Third Amendment prevents New York from forcing residents to house illegal aliens.
-PJ