Posted on 08/10/2023 6:10:01 AM PDT by SoConPubbie
I have been researching the MACRO economic dynamic in Russia quite deeply for the past six months. Essentially looking to discover not only what impact the western imposed sanctions might be having, but more broadly looking to see what happens to self-sustainability when essentially locked out from the world of commercial imports.
The research is fascinating, not simply because it is a unique opportunity, but also because national economic issues play a big role in the overall social dynamic. That said, I can say the social aspect is stunningly more interesting than the data driven outcomes. When you really dig deep into actual life of the ordinary people in Russia, far away from the geopolitical contexts, you get an entirely different perspective. My worldview of the average Russian person/family has completely changed.
There is a really good thread on how the western sanctions against Russia are having a much lesser impact than initially thought [SEE HERE]. On the economic side, one thing I would point to is how the economy is essentially an outcome of two facets: (1) the internal production strength, and (2) the service side of the ledger.
The author makes the accurate point that from a production side perspective, Russia actually has a larger economy now than Germany, the largest EU nation. The cause for this is “autarchy” or self-sufficiency. Indeed, as the timeline of the sanctions closes in on the second year completing, the Russian production economy is even stronger than when the sanctions began. Quite simply, they are making even more of their own goods now.
The sanctions hit what would typically fall into the service side of the economy, as well as financial and economic roadblocks. However, that aspect of the Russian economy was much smaller than most suspected and there were sanctions going back to 2014 which made the outcome of the 2022 western imposed restrictions less impactful.
I will be finishing my review of the economic data once Q3 is over, that will give me an entire year of data to share. However, the social stuff is even more fascinating.
I have a new understanding of why former NSA contractor Edward Snowden was so comfortable using Russia as the place to hide after his release of classified intelligence showing how the U.S. government was spying on Americans via social media and metadata collection.
I have mostly been looking at three areas in Western Russia. Kazan, Moscow and St Petersburg (formerly Leningrad). Of the three generally large metropolitan areas, St Petersburg is by far the most interesting. It’s beautiful there and the city is alive and vibrant.
In many ways you might compare Russia in 2023 to the USA in/around 1988. Life is just not complicated and far more socially engaged.
I’ll have more on this later, but if you are ever bored check out the Russian YouTubers who livestream broadcast “a day-in-the-life” type of activity. The infrastructure is in generally good repair, the people seem warm and friendly and there is a strong social value placed on family and kids.
There are certainly negatives and the cultural dynamic of the former USSR is still evident. Technologically they are somewhat behind in some details, but the overall cohesion of their value system is something I did not fully appreciate until I started down this road of research.
I can see why the average Russian could be wide-eyed during a visit to the USA and fascinated with the overall quality of life that might be considered indulgent. However, I can also see how reciprocally the average American could be wide-eyed and smiling at the overall sense of the Russian people.
Strip out the politics, and we are all much more similar than we are different.
Forgotten is the fact that short of nuclear weapons, the West has done everything in its power to harm the Russians. There’s no cards left for the West to play. The Russians are stronger today than before the sanctions while the West hobbles around on two self inflicted gunshot wounded feet.
Russia has oil, gas, titanium, gold and lithium. What could it possibly need from the West? Diversity? Equity? Inclusion? Sexual deviancy? “The West” has a surplus of insanity and that’s not really a viable export.
One minute Russia is bankrupt. The next they are thriving. Nobody seems to know for sure. I guess these opinions pass as news. That’s the problem. Opinions have become facts.
One recalls that this was a part of the political turmoil surrounding Trump, wherein such phrases as "drill, baby, drill" and the like were essentially about some form of autarchy for us in terms of energy.
Placing this into the larger frame of history, from 1977 on, we were told that government was going to stabilize and strengthen US energy in the aftermath of the 1973 oil embargo. That's been 46 years of "energy" and in today's "environmental" world, we are supposed to still be energy-rich if not energy-autonomous. But we aren't.
Carter forward, politics has worked against this. Recall, courtesy of Wiki ---
The United States Department of Energy (DOE) is an executive department of the U.S. federal government that oversees U.S. national energy policy and manages the research and development of nuclear power, the military's nuclear weapons program, nuclear reactor production for the United States Navy, energy-related research, and domestic energy production and energy conservation.Trump wanted to see us energy-prosperous, and since the Biden (Obama) team again took the reins of power, we have been further weakened and energy costs have ramped up significantly. Some win thereby, but most lose.
This must be changed. The US has the chance to be an "autarchy" in many things, excepting the multi-nationals and internationalists work against this each and every day.
America’s energy policy for 50 years was spending hundreds of billions protecting the Strait of Hormuz and very little else.
Russia is NOT losing this war against Biden, Biden is losing.
We aren't supposed to have noticed that.
Now if one were to tally up all the failed "renewables" companies from Obama forward, all of which went bankrupt with more doing so now, one sees a pattern. Lots of voters cannot. The pattern is corruption.
Meanwhile China -- the Biden-Granholm connection -- builds coal plants and coal plants and coal plants....
Demographics has a lot to do with the survival of a civilization. We have been indoctrinated to believe that “diversity is strength, homogeneity is weakness”.
Time will tell which model prevails.
The sanctions may not be affecting the Russian economy all that much but they are killing our US economy. - thank you, Joe!!!
Gee, shocker 🙄
Another reason why these neocon, Russian haters are so evil. Russia is everything Ronald Reagan could have hoped today after the fall of communism.
But, Putin nor the Russians will bow down to the masters of the liberal world order and its agenda (destroying and subjugating countries for to enrich themselves) and are constantly being demonized and smeared, including on this site.
Under Biden, we are the new evil empire. Russia is becoming the shining city on hill, especially for Christians.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.