You, my friend are a rare breed on FReeRepublic!
You are advocating some kind of guidelines where the government can violate the 2ND Amendment?
BTW: Once those Guidelines are approved for the 2nd .. I’m sure that guidelines for all of the other amendments will follow!
What if the state that you reside in were to pass a law that says: “Guns are a public health menace so they will be confiscated?”
You okay with that too?
“The Second Amendment to the Constitution isn’t for just protecting hunting rights, and it’s not only to safeguard your right to target practice.
It is a Constitutional right to protect your children, your family, your home, our lives, and to serve as the ultimate check against governmental tyranny ... for the protection of liberty.”
(Ted Cruz)
You could always constitutionally guarantee the shall issue nature of the licence to ensure that the government cannot arbitrarily pass gun laws that allow them to just take guns away because they hate guns and they can. You say that the government could potentially repeal that law and make it so the state could just grab guns arbitrarily but in theory, they could also repeal the second amendment by the same token.