(Doris Day: my very first crush ever)
1958 Catch a Falling Star / Magic Moments Perry Como
1959 The Three Bells The Browns
1951 Cold, Cold Heart Tony Bennett
1955 Love Is a Many-Splendored Thing The Four Aces
1957 Singing the Blues Guy Mitchell
1954 (Oh Baby Mine) I Get So Lonely The Four Knights [also titled as I Get So Lonely (When I Dream About You)]
1952 Wish You Were Here Eddie Fisher
1950 Third Man Theme Guy Lombardo
I guess the 1953 song is last on your list, then?