No comment after that, I just wanted to read it again.
I will point out for those who carry, Hornady Critical Defense is very good out of short-barreled semis. I find it more recoil-controllable than its +P cousin Critical Duty, which, I think, is better suited to the 4- and 5-inch barrels of duty guns. YMMV, of course. It's as shootable as range ammo out of my Micro 9.
“I will point out for those who carry, Hornady Critical Defense is very good out of short-barreled semis.”
Not good for full-size 1911s?