I disagree. Allow them some type of permanent status short of citizenship. This is the penalty for breaking our immigration laws. And give them this only after we have gotten the enforcement plus the wall plus ending chain migration.
I respect your opinion, but I cannot see the rats ever agreeing to that. Truthfully, I cannot see them even agreeing to my extremely generous concession, so if they’re going to walk away, voters might as well see them walking away from an eminently reasonable deal instead of your maximal demands (which would be my policy preference of I had my druthers).
The thing that worries me the most is the next Democrat or open borders GOP president. Before long, we will lose the country to demographic shifts without a permanent border barrier that is immune from the whims of politicians, so we need to do anything possible to get it. Otherwise, we’re just going to continue having floods of aliens and anchor baby citizens voting in even more of them until the country resembles California.