Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

To: nathanbedford
If a president cannot be perfectly certain that his carrier will survive incursions into the South China Sea, dare he venture?

Military craft are constructed so as to routinely venture into harm's way. What kind of leader would someone be if they allowed the mere possibility of an attack to dissuade them from completing a mission?

While it's obviously unwise to be needlessly provocative, it's also the case that the liberty to "sail the ocean blue" is a critical adjunct of free civilization. If China threatens to create Tyranny on the high seas, they should be challenged by any nation with the wherewithal to do so...

6 posted on 01/29/2017 11:47:45 PM PST by sargon (LS sez: "The Uniparty Establishment has NO idea what's about to hit them!")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies ]


To: sargon
We are $20 trillion in debt, we are facing more than $200 trillion in unfunded liabilities, in short we are on the verge of a financial crisis.

In the face of that crisis President Trump is taking a huge gamble. For the record, I endorse the gamble as the only viable hope to negotiate the reckoning to come but that does not mean that I think success is assured, or even likely. Nor does it mean that I think that Trump is entirely correct in some particulars.

The president is gambling that he can revive the economy before the reckoning by stimulating it with tax cuts and invigorating it with trade reform and protecting it by very marginal and mostly insignificant cuts. Unfortunately, he shows no disposition to address entitlements which is the only way that our debt crisis can be avoided, especially if GDP growth at about the rate of at least 4% (probably 6% to 7% will be required) is not attained. He is doing this for purely political reasons. Worse, he has campaigned on creating a new entitlement which, no matter how camouflaged as tax credits, is still an entitlement.

In addition to cutting taxes, keeping expensive provisions of Obama Care, he intends to spend $1 trillion on infrastructure. Finally, he wants to spend what it takes to revive our military from the grossly ill-conceived administration of Barack Obama. Every one of these expenditures, when coupled with the tax cut, at least in the short term creates larger deficits, enhances the debt and increases the need for Mr. Trump to win his gamble even while it lowers the odds that he will succeed.

When we talk about rebuilding our military is is essential that we talk about establishing priorities. Priorities do not come wholly formed, sprung from the brain of some great thinker, they come from assessing the nations strategic needs. The weapon systems should be created to serve those needs and that raises the question whether super carriers times 11 are the most efficient way to maintain the freedom of the seas, to protect our allies (if that is our mission-which is questionable) in Asian waters or even to maintain trade routes safe for China trade?

In making these assessments we should at least have the prudence to admit that our resources are limited, that are chances to correct mistakes are diminishing, that our adversaries are waxing in strength, that we dare not get this wrong.

I see the sequence for American security as follows: (1) restore the economy; (2) cut spending by reforming entitlements; (3) rebuild the military. Without (1) and (2) we will never have a long-lasting military. Indeed, if we get the military part wrong, if we overspend, if we misconceive our strategic goals and weapons needs we can actually impede obtaining a restored economy.

There is much to be considered before we wave the flag and conclude that we will sail into harms way with the Navy band playing Anchors Away


14 posted on 01/30/2017 12:37:33 AM PST by nathanbedford (attack, repeat, attack! Bull Halsey)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson