Michigan legislative action thread
Posted on 01/18/2016 10:02:55 AM PST by MichCapCon
On Tuesday, Gov. Rick Snyder signed into law Senate Bill 13, which eliminates the option on election ballots to vote a straight party ticket with a single action. Michigan voters who want to vote a straight-party ticket can still do so, but will have to mark their votes for each candidate one at a time.
Some evidence suggests that Democratic voters use the straight-party voting option more than Republican voters do. Republicans in Michigan have tended to support eliminating it, while Democrats have been united behind keeping it in place.
This marks the third time the Michigan Legislature has voted to repeal the option. The two previous attempts in 1964 and 2001 were subsequently undone by citizen-initiated referendums. This time, however, the legislation included a modest appropriation, which under the Michigan Constitution makes the new law referendum-proof.
"I think it will marginally help Republicans," said Inside Michigan Politics founder Bill Ballenger. "There are some places in the state where a lot of Republicans vote straight party, but even more portions — particularly in urban areas — where large numbers of Democrats do. The change should be slightly to the advantage of the Republicans. I think the Republicans made a mistake 13 years ago by not putting an appropriation in the legislation to prevent the 2002 referendum. Former Michigan Democratic Party Chairman Mark Brewer pounced on that immediately and got it on the ballot so the voters could reverse it."
"I would say that the Democrats do have a point when they argue that the voters turned this down 13 years ago by a solid majority," Ballenger continued. "But I don’t think that will matter very much. I mean, I don’t think there will be any backlash against the Republicans for this in upcoming elections."
Democrats have argued that eliminating the straight-ticket voting option would cause confusion and frustration among voters and result in longer lines at the polls. In some urban areas, voters have had to wait in line for hours to cast their votes. Although it is estimated that the change would add an average of 30 seconds to the time it takes a voter to cast a ballot, cumulatively it could result in a longer wait for many voters.
Meanwhile, Michigan Democratic Party Chairman Brandon Dillon has suggested that a challenge to the law could be mounted in the courts.
Arguments in favor of eliminating the straight-party option include the fact that most states no longer have it. Until Snyder signed Senate Bill 13 into law, Michigan was one of only 10 states that still had it. The others are: Alabama, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas, and Utah.
Supporters of the new law argue that voters ought to educate themselves about prospective officeholders and that the absence of the straight-ticket option could encourage them to do so. Back in 2002, it was also argued that its presence unfairly puts candidates representing alternative parties such as the Libertarian Party and the Green Party at a disadvantage. It was also pointed out then that the movement to eliminate the straight ticket in Massachusetts — during the first half of the 20th century — was led by the Kennedy family. At that time, Massachusetts was predominantly a Republican-voting state.
In a news release announcing that he signed the bill, Snyder said, “Michigan is one of only 10 states that allow residents to vote for just a party affiliation rather than individual people. … It’s time to choose people over politics.†A letter signed by the governor accompanying the bill signing explains why he also is also asking the Legislature to enact no-reason absentee voting.
As Senate Bill 13 worked its way through the Legislature, Republicans openly rejected efforts to also include no-reason absentee voting.
In reaction to Snyder's act, the left-wing group, Progress Michigan, issued a news release with the headline: ‘Snyder Signs Partisan Move to Lengthen Lines at Polls.’ The subhead beneath this headline read 'Eliminating straight-party ticket voting another conservative attempt to rig elections.'
Senate Bill 13 was sponsored by Sen. Marty Knollenberg, R-Troy. It is now Public Act 268 of 2015. The appropriation that was added to it allocates $5 million to the Secretary of State for voting equipment that might be needed to implement the law.
Good, that eliminates one of the voter fraud avenues.
Finally.
This will do serious damage to the democrats who rely on simple minded (D) on their ballots.
Longer lines could be reduced considerably if people only voted once. Turnout is already too high among morons and zombies.
It causes confusion among voters if they can’t vote straight Democrat?? Really?? Its that hard to find the Democrat running for each office e and vote for the candidate of your choice???
Democrats have lazy voters.
Its just too much work for them to punch different ballot slots.
Of course, you have the right to be a stupid voter, too.
I don’t like the change. I’ve voted straight Republican for decades. I will no longer do so.
Yeah, well, boo-hoo to them. Make ‘em work for it!
The problem with straight ticket voting in Michigan is that it counted as a “No vote” in races where there is more than one republican running for one seat like college regents.
I don’t like the change. I’ve voted straight Republican for decades. I will no longer do so.
********************************************************************
Well, good for you...now, even though you don’t like it, you’ll actually have to think about for whom you are voting for each office.
There, I fixed it so that it would apply to the equally confused elderly people out there who may be Republicans..........
CC, put me on the MI Ping list. Yes they will, and Tangent to it is GOP voters will have to get smarter with their down-ticket candidates on the Ballot. The Rattle with Us folks have been great about trying to educate voters about this. Case in point Doc' Steele running and getting in as a Regent @ U of MI, I wonder if this education ( statewide perhaps, with other Tea Party Groups ) lead to Doc's victory and in the future, will it yield like victories.
“The problem with straight ticket voting in Michigan is that it counted as a “No vote†in races where there is more than one republican running for one seat like college regents.”
I did not know that. Thanks for the info.
The story sounds like it will marginally help the GOP but I suspect it will be considerably more than marginal.
Its kind of like our “open” primary. It may be open but you can only vote for one party or the other on a primary ballot. I think it kills a lot of potential crossover voting which is fine with me.
This is obviously racist
The “confusion” and “concern” trolls are concerned and confused with all of the informed vote confusion over how to get their people to vote correctly.
The democrat plantation must be steeped in all sorts of disarray and apoplexy over this.
“Its that hard to find the Democrat running for each office e and vote for the candidate of your choice???”
Many of them in the ‘D’ can’t read! More than 50%!
I’ve always dont it anyway.
Was too paranoid that any mistake would make the whole ballot get rejected. And I rather enjoyed filling in the holes and knowing that I voted on each selection and didnt just leave it up to the machine.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.