Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Marcus: Cruz not disqualified
The Casper Star-Tribune ^ | January 7, 2016 | Ruth Marcus

Posted on 01/07/2016 6:27:40 PM PST by 2ndDivisionVet

The issue of whether Ted Cruz is constitutionally eligible to be president could not be more bogus. He is. Case closed.

I say this as someone who could scarcely be more concerned about the prospect of President Cruz. So concerned, in fact, that I have concluded, after much angsting, that President Trump would be preferable, given that nightmare choice. But notwithstanding Trump's typically ill-informed and situational insinuations (he didn't see any problem with Cruz having been born in Canada before Cruz posed a real threat), the constitutional requirement that the president be a natural-born citizen does not disqualify Cruz.

Article II, Section One, Clause 5 of the Constitution, setting out minimum requirements for the presidency, does not define the meaning of "natural-born citizen," a limitation intended, as John Jay wrote in a letter to George Washington, to "provide a strong check to the admission of Foreigners into the administration of our national Government."

Taken in a vacuum, "natural-born" is arguably ambiguous. It could be interpreted to apply to all who are citizens at birth, rather than those required to go through a naturalization proceeding to attain citizenship.

Or -- although this seems the more tortured analysis -- it could be interpreted to exclude those born outside the physical jurisdiction of the United States to citizen parents. That would include Cruz, who was born in Canada to a U.S citizen mother, and, therefore, automatically a citizen himself....

(Excerpt) Read more at trib.com ...


TOPICS: Conspiracy; Government; Politics
KEYWORDS: cruz; naturalborncitizen; tedcruz; trump

1 posted on 01/07/2016 6:27:41 PM PST by 2ndDivisionVet
[ Post Reply]

To: 2ndDivisionVet

I appreciate this. Funny author.


2 posted on 01/07/2016 6:31:16 PM PST by The Ghost of FReepers Past (Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light..... Isaiah 5:20)
[ Post Reply]

To: 2ndDivisionVet
Cruz not disqualified

True. But there is no shortage of bots who believe he is.

3 posted on 01/07/2016 6:39:54 PM PST by South40 (Ted Cruz = the only conservative in the race)
[ Post Reply]

To: 2ndDivisionVet

I am reminded of Bob Beckel who, before he was bounced by Fox, used to announce every other day that “Cruz is my man!” - because he thought Cruz would be so easy to defeat in 2016 - beware of loony lefties saying supportive things about conservatives.....


4 posted on 01/07/2016 6:40:07 PM PST by Intolerant in NJ
[ Post Reply]

To: 2ndDivisionVet

All the ado May in the end help Cruz get the question behind him.


5 posted on 01/07/2016 6:50:23 PM PST by inpajamas (Texas Akbar!!!!!!!)
[ Post Reply]

To: 2ndDivisionVet
Cruz appears here to take opposite positions on birthright citizenship

Could a Cruz supporter explain the apparent contradiction in this youtube?
6 posted on 01/07/2016 6:51:50 PM PST by jobim
[ Post Reply]

To: South40
True. But there is no shortage of bots who believe he is.

And there is no shortage of democrats who won't take advantage of this. Cruz will be tied up in litigation for years and dems are licking their lips as they anticipate this.

7 posted on 01/07/2016 6:56:28 PM PST by DouglasKC (I'm pro-choice when it comes to lion killing....)
[ Post Reply]

To: South40; 2ndDivisionVet
True. But there is no shortage of bots who believe he is.

Or members of the Trump Personality Cult that want to keep pushing the false meme in hopes of convincing the less informed and those unwilling to do research.
8 posted on 01/07/2016 7:09:27 PM PST by SoConPubbie (Mitt and Obama: They're the same poison, just a different potency)
[ Post Reply]

To: SoConPubbie
Or members of the Trump Personality Cult that want to keep pushing the false meme in hopes of convincing the less informed and those unwilling to do research.

That, and the bots are trying to use this to try to justify their support for lifelong liberal Donald Trump.

They remind me of Alan Grayson as they have most assuredly sided with him on this issue.

9 posted on 01/07/2016 7:15:22 PM PST by South40 (Ted Cruz = the only conservative in the race)
[ Post Reply]

To: jobim

“Could a Cruz supporter explain the apparent contradiction in this youtube?”

Yes, they will, as in the cliche: “Shut up, he explained!!!”

And, by the way, you are a terrible person.


10 posted on 01/07/2016 7:20:49 PM PST by odawg
[ Post Reply]

To: jobim

By the way, maybe they can also explain the lapse in Cruz’s perfect memory (since he is incapable of dishonesty) that they were all gaga over when he named off some questions during a debate; first time anything like that has ever happened in world history. Glenn Beck claimed he used a computer to check that. (?)


11 posted on 01/07/2016 7:24:31 PM PST by odawg
[ Post Reply]

To: jobim

Now that I have stopped laughing, mostly, I can explain it. He was running in Texas and was pandering to the Hispanic vote. Now he is running to a larger group, and doesn’t need to pander so much, and has discovered that Hispanic don’t necessarily favor it either.

This will discombobulate some Cruz supporters until they sleep on it and dream up something to explain it completely away.


12 posted on 01/07/2016 7:30:06 PM PST by odawg
[ Post Reply]

To: 2ndDivisionVet

IRREFUTABLE AUTHORITY HAS SPOKEN
(Oct. 18, 2009) — The Post & Email has in several articles mentioned that the Supreme Court of the United States has given the definition of what a “natural born citizen” is. Since being a natural born citizen is an objective qualification and requirement of office for the U.S. President, it is important for all U.S. Citizens to understand what this term means.

http://www.thepostemail.com/2009/10/18/4-supreme-court-cases-define-natural-born-citizen/


13 posted on 01/07/2016 8:03:19 PM PST by Leo Carpathian (FReeeeepeesssssed)
[ Post Reply]

To: 2ndDivisionVet

Every time I see one of these “geniuses” opine on this topic, I laugh. Same old nonsense arguments. Always the same.


14 posted on 01/07/2016 8:10:55 PM PST by DiogenesLamp ("of parents owing allegiance to no other sovereignty.")
[ Post Reply]

To: South40; All

First, I’ll start off saying that I like Cruz and Trump. Each has their merits. What surprises me is the shear ignorance between some Trump and Cruz supporters on FR. Some are so narrow minded, that they read an article posted online and believe it without researching what actually happened or keeping an open mind. Did we all forget that the Media hates conservatives and the GOP base? Are we really that stupid? I can admit that I’m guilty of it, but there are some that have some serious blinders on.

Secondly, I doubt Cruz is ineligible. That being said. I don’t believe Trump attacked Cruz. Trump was asked a loaded question by a reporter. Trump said (Paraphrasing/Summarizing), “It could be a problem. He is unsure if he is eligible. Cruz should squash this as soon as possible.” Could Trump have worded his exact response better, sure. But analyze what he actually said.

“It could be a problem.” Yes, it could be a problem. If you think that the Dems/GOPe, didn’t know about this or didn’t do anything before Trump said anything, you are a fool. Several lawsuits were already filed in several states, that questioned Cruz, Rubio, and Jindal’s eligibility. Jindal has been out of the race for sometime.

“Trump is unsure if he is eligible.” The issue here is that while his mother was US Citizen living in Canada at the time of his birth, did she file the necessary paperwork and meet the stipulated requirements within the documents to the US Embassy/Consulate to have her son Ted listed as a US citizen at birth. These records are sealed and have not been released. Without the release of these docs, how is anyone (including Trump) supposed to know for sure. This is the easiest way for Cruz to squash this.

“Cruz should squash this soon as possible”. This coincides with the above parts. Trump isn’t Cruz’s spokesman and doesn’t have to defend Cruz. Trump stated correctly that the issue at hand is Cruz’s and it is his to take care of. The sooner Cruz squashes this, the better as it could damper his chances of being nominated and possibly winning the general.


15 posted on 01/08/2016 3:58:21 AM PST by PJBankard (It is better to be thought an idiot than to open ones mouth and remove all doubt.)
[ Post Reply]

To: DouglasKC
Cruz will be tied up in litigation for years and dems are licking their lips as they anticipate this.

So was Obama. And it didn't seem to stop him from doing whatever he wanted. And, oh yeah. He's still there.

This lawsuit threat is overblown.

16 posted on 01/08/2016 7:31:24 AM PST by BfloGuy ( Even the opponents of Socialism are dominated by socialist ideas.)
[ Post Reply]

To: jobim

“...the apparent contradiction...”

In the first video, he clearly says that the only reason it’s a problem is because we incentivize illegal immigration and looks to deal with birthright citizenship by combating illegal immigration. In the latter video, he is still looking to deal with birthright citizenship but doesn’t really say how because the video is edited/cut. In fact, both videos are spliced/edited/cut so what was the full story?

I agree with Cruz — If someone is here *LEGALLY*, why would we want to deny their children birthright citizenship? In the edited portions of the videos presented, Cruz seems consistent in that illegal aliens should not be granted birthright citizenship and I agree with that too. The devil is in the detail of how you accomplish that. No president can do it unilaterally - they will need to go through congress and it could quite possibly involve amending the Constitution. So who is your candidate and how would they eliminate birthright citizenship?

Best of luck with your candidate!


17 posted on 01/08/2016 8:34:18 AM PST by jaydee770
[ Post Reply]

To: Leo Carpathian

“...IRREFUTABLE AUTHORITY HAS SPOKEN...”

Oh, it’s entirely refutable. Which of those cases defines NBC as to presidential qualifications? They may be used to argue one way or another in a case specifically intended to define Presidential qualifications and they may or may not prevail, but until someone does bring a case that settles the matter specifically regarding presidential qualifications, we have to look elsewhere. Blame the lawyers and judges — it’s their system that requires the specificity (not mine).

Also, the article cites those who “understood what the framers of the Constitution intended”. Yet in the Naturalization Act of 1790, written by a congress that included 8 of the 11 framers of the US Constitution, it reveals in their own written words in the legislative record, specifically how they regarded the circumstance of birth like Ted Cruz’s and it FLATLY REFUTES the article.

“...just three years after the Constitution was drafted, the First Congress weighed in. The Naturalization Act of 1790 provided that “the children of citizens of the United States, that may be born beyond sea, or out of the limits of the United States, shall be considered as Natural Born Citizens.” As Katyal and Clement note, that evidence is “particularly persuasive because so many of the framers of the Constitution were also members of the First Congress. That is particularly true in this instance, as eight of the 11 members of the committee that proposed the natural-born eligibility requirement to the Convention served in the First Congress and none objected to a definition of ‘natural-born citizen’ that included persons born abroad to citizen parents.”...”

So in their own words, we can definitely say the founding fathers would have accepted him as a Presidential candidate with his circumstance of birth. Now, when it comes to “Legally speaking”, the only law that applies is whatever was in place on the date Cruz was born — not before; not after. But as to “opinion” and what was clearly acceptable to the founders, we can read their very words and have no doubt. Whatever eventually happens, it will not change the written, clear, unambiguous point of view of the founding fathers on the issue, which if they were to be allowed any input, clearly states that “the children of citizens of the United States, that may be born beyond sea, or out of the limits of the United States, shall be considered as natural born citizens”. For the sake of argument, Justices Sotomayor, Kagen, Ginsburg, Breyer and Kennedy could implausibly & theoretically one day rule that “simply asking to be a citizen is sufficient to bestow NBC status” (or whatever, it’s just a silly example). But the point is that no matter what they may or may not rule tomorrow, it would not change how the founding fathers felt about it and saw fit to legislate on the matter - presuming their opinion should be taken into consideration at all. My opinion is that if it was good enough for the founders, who am I to argue with them?


18 posted on 01/08/2016 9:01:35 AM PST by jaydee770
[ Post Reply]

To: BfloGuy
So was Obama. And it didn't seem to stop him from doing whatever he wanted. And, oh yeah. He's still there. This lawsuit threat is overblown.

Obama wasn't seriously challenged. The Republican party wanted no part of it. Judges dismissed anybody who sued as nutcases who had no standing. That will be different with Cruz. The press and the whole Democrat party will be clamoring for a legal remedy. They will find a judge who will do whatever they want. It will go to the Supreme court and those idiots will disallow Cruz based purely on ideology .

19 posted on 01/08/2016 9:17:45 AM PST by DouglasKC (I'm pro-choice when it comes to lion killing....)
[ Post Reply]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson