Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Don’t Blame Employees for Pension Underfunding
Capitol Confidential ^ | 1/2/2016 | James Hohman

Posted on 01/05/2016 9:34:33 AM PST by MichCapCon

It is unfortunate that government employees are often blamed for underfunded government pension systems. When concerns are raised that retirement systems owe members billions more than has been saved, high-earners and early retirees are viewed as the culprits. Policymakers in return cut the generosity of the plans. Yet these policy reforms will not fix the basic problems faced by pension systems.

In 2010, Michigan’s school employee pension system was underfunded by $12 billion, not including the value of promised retiree health care benefits. Lawmakers sprang into action. They increased employee contributions to the system and made new employees' benefits less generous.

In 2012, Michigan’s school employee pension system was underfunded by $22.4 billion, not including the value of promised retiree health care benefits. Once again, lawmakers sprang into action. They increased employee contributions to the system, made benefits offered to new employees less generous, and reduced some of the benefits of current retirement system members.

These reforms made lots of changes to Michigan public school employee retirement benefits, but their focus on generous benefits as the cause of underfunding was misguided.

The $10.4 billion growth in unfunded liabilities between the two reforms was not due to more people gaming the system (although it happens). It wasn't the result of employees not paying their fair share into the system. The real culprit was the state’s failure to meet the system’s own actuarial assumptions of how much needs to be contributed each year to cover future benefits.

A 2014 performance audit of the retirement system found that the lack of investment gains compared to their assumed returns was responsible for 93 percent of the underfunding over the past 10 years.

Lawmakers made the system less generous to employees based on assumption that generous benefits were behind the underfunding problem. But actually, it was the system's underlying assumptions about the pension fund's projected investment returns that caused the most damage.

A few minor things have been done about this. The 2012 reforms allowed new employees to participate in a defined-contribution retirement plan, and roughly 20 percent choose this option. The 2010 reforms also reduced the assumed return on pension fund investments from 8 percent to 7 percent for newer system members. These are improvements.

But in the end, the solution is clear: The state should stop putting new school employees in defined-benefit pension plans. Instead of tinkering with a failed model, all new school employees should be offered defined-contribution retirement benefits instead.

These plans belong to employees themselves and are are paid as they are earned, which makes it impossible for the state to generate billions of future unfunded liabilities on their behalf. Preventing new liabilities will help the state honor the pension promises already made to current staff and retirees. Because it's not their fault the state has failed to properly fund their retirement benefits.


TOPICS: Government
KEYWORDS: pensions

1 posted on 01/05/2016 9:34:33 AM PST by MichCapCon
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon

I don’t care what they do in Michigan. I want not one dime of my tax money going to these bloated bureaucrat pensions ZERO!


2 posted on 01/05/2016 9:37:19 AM PST by WENDLE (Trump is not bought . He is no puppet.)
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon

OK, but (then also) don’t blame innocent, hard-working, tax-paying Americans, who have worked and sacrificed all of their adult lives, in hopes of one day retiring on their own savings. Don’t take from them for underfunded public employee pensions.


3 posted on 01/05/2016 9:39:29 AM PST by NEMDF
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon

Bottom line—people living off of other peoples taxes. However if the people/voters continue to elect the same nitwits who enable the system to churn on as is, then they, the voters/people, deserve ever last ‘thrust’ they receive.


4 posted on 01/05/2016 9:40:28 AM PST by yadent
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon

I do. It is a crony-induced system that is unsustainable. The need to default and restructure to something reasonable.


5 posted on 01/05/2016 9:49:42 AM PST by aMorePerfectUnion (As a representative of Earth, I officially welcome Global Warming to our planet)
[ Post Reply]

To: WENDLE

BINGO!!! Let the system collapse and start over!


6 posted on 01/05/2016 9:50:15 AM PST by SgtHooper (If you remember the 60's, YOU WEREN'T THERE!)
[ Post Reply]

To: aMorePerfectUnion

Many of the politician’s who don’t fund the retirement funds are actually elected with the support of public employees unions or were public employee union members. They keep the contributions low so that they can hide the real expense of these benefits..eventually it will come out, but the figure they can get the taxpayers to bail them out.


7 posted on 01/05/2016 10:17:20 AM PST by Oldexpat
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon

The Unions bought their largess with ever democrat vote.


8 posted on 01/05/2016 10:32:26 AM PST by stocksthatgoup (Trump and Cruz are not attacking each other. Why don't their follows take note)
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon

It’s shared blame between the employees, who use union coercion to demand unsustainable benefits, and the politicians who comply rather than cross the unions.


9 posted on 01/05/2016 11:23:47 AM PST by Boogieman
[ Post Reply]

To: NEMDF

They’re not innocent. They have coerced the government, through union tactics that should be outlawed, into enriching them from the public treasury, to the detriment of their fellow citizens.

These people are supposed to be civil servants, not greedy looters, but that is what they have become.


10 posted on 01/05/2016 11:24:58 AM PST by Boogieman
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon

Government entities should be forced to fund future benefits on a year to year basis just like corporate entities.

Why are government entities exempt from funding?

Forcing funding would result in having to look at the benefits themselves.


11 posted on 01/05/2016 11:33:47 AM PST by relentlessly
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon
A 2014 performance audit of the retirement system found that the lack of investment gains compared to their assumed returns was responsible for 93 percent of the underfunding over the past 10 years.

Translation: the people managing the pension fund investment portfolio were incompetent.

12 posted on 01/05/2016 11:37:59 AM PST by PapaBear3625 (Big government is attractive to those who think that THEY will be in control of it.)
[ Post Reply]

To: Boogieman

I did not mean to imply that these public sector workers are innocent.

I meant to make the point that, those of us who are NOT public sector workers are innocent, and should not be penalized for the underfunding problems.


13 posted on 01/05/2016 11:38:06 AM PST by NEMDF
[ Post Reply]

To: MichCapCon
It is unfortunate that government employees are often blamed for underfunded government pension systems.

Actually, the employees, members of public sector unions who vote themselves these stupidly outlandish pensions to be funded on the back of the taxpayers for whom there are no golden parachutes should bear part of the blame.

Instead, the taxpayer who is required to sacrifice to pay for it shoulders the burden of blame, in the government employee's eyes.

14 posted on 01/05/2016 11:41:30 AM PST by MortMan (I am offended by those who believe they have a right not to be offended.)
[ Post Reply]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson