What the heck do you mean, you can’t punish someone for the actions they MAY choose? Of course, we can and do. Seems like this guy is getting punished for the actions he CHOSE! Your rant is just too weird - and kind of wrong - so I’ll leaveit at that.
Uhhhh - no. Police dogs, active or retired, are not "magic". You seem to be contending that they are, and LevinFan rightly begged to differ. So, he's not wrong.
And people wonder how the German people were led down the primrose path after the Weimar Republic...