We are running the programmer joke by those who write our specs. We want to know what a software tester would do with those instructions.
I’m a BA. That’s one of the reasons I thought it was so funny. I also wear SA and TA hats from time to time, btw, so that one really did speak to the pitfalls of what I do.
A software tester would pass the scenario based on the business requirement. Now a quality assurance professional would realize the business requirement was wrong and raise an issue.