[kabumpo]

Number one, I’m not a musician. And number 2, yes they were Jews - certainly perceived to be in Russia. And I know many secular Jews who define themselves as Jewish, even though they never set foot in a synagogue.
What.counts in this case is.not the number of Jews.that there were in the Bolshevik party overall, but the high concentration of them in the inner circle, and the power that they wielded.

[rmlew]

Number one, I’m not a musician. And number 2, yes they were Jews - certainly perceived to be in Russia. And I know many secular Jews who define themselves as Jewish, even though they never set foot in a synagogue. What.counts in this case is.not the number of Jews.that there were in the Bolshevik party overall, but the high concentration of them in the inner circle, and the power that they wielded.

Russian antisemitism has very old roots. Facts are rarely relevant.
Your position is that people of Jewish descent who are not part of the religion, and who then join an atheist death cult dedicated to irradicating Judaism and Jewishness are still Jews?
Sorry, but they are the worst forms of APOSTATES.